|
|
Title: Identification of
etiology of autism
United States Patent: 7,252,957
Issued: August 7, 2007
Inventors: Vojdani; Aristo
(Los Angeles, CA)
Assignee: Immunosciences
Lab., Inc. (Beverly Hills, CA)
Appl. No.: 10/770,712
Filed: February 3, 2004
|
|
|
Training Courses -- Pharm/Biotech/etc.
|
Abstract
Disclosed herein is a method for
following up a prognosis of children with autism before and after
treatment with different modalities administered by their clinicians,
confirming the involvement of infectious agents, dietary proteins, and
toxic chemicals in development of autism. The method utilizes detection of
increased amounts of antibodies against an antigen based on infectious
agent, toxic chemicals, or dietary proteins. Another method utilizes
detection of antibodies to a self-tissue or peptide.
SUMMARY OF THE
INVENTION
An embodiment provides for a method for
determining etiology of an autistic spectrum disorder in a patient,
comprising the steps of: a) determining a level of at least one infectious
agent derived antigen or antibody against an infectious agent derived
antigen, at least one toxic chemical derived antigen or an antibody
against a toxic chemical, and at least one dietary protein derived antigen
or antibody against a dietary protein, in one or more samples from the
patient; b) comparing the level of antigens and/or antibodies determined
in step a) with a normal level of the antigens and/or antibodies from
control subjects, wherein (i) normal level or lower than normal level of
antigens and/or antibodies for the each of said antigens indicate absence
of an etiology of autistic spectrum disorder from presence of said
antigens; and (ii) higher than normal level of antigens and/or antibodies
for one or more of said antigens and/or antibodies indicates a likelihood
of the autistic spectrum disorder being based on the presence of said
antigens.
Another embodiment provides for a method for determining etiology of an
autistic spectrum disorder in a patient, comprising the steps of: a)
determining a level of antibodies to a self-tissue or peptide in one or
more samples from the patient; and b) comparing the level of antibodies
determined in step a) with a normal level of the antibodies from control
subjects, wherein (i) normal level or lower than normal levels of
antibodies indicate absence of etiology of autistic spectrum disorder from
presence of said antibodies; and (ii) higher than normal level of the
antibodies indicates a likelihood of the autistic spectrum disorder being
based on the presence of said antibodies.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
Similar to many complex diseases (10),
genetic and environmental factors including infections, xenobiotics,
dietary proteins and peptides, play a role in the development of autism.
The effects of environmental factors on genetic makeup can result in
immune, gastrointestinal, neurological, biochemical and neuroimmunological
abnormalities. Based on extensive research (11-15), we postulated that
autism is induced by infectious agent antigens, toxic chemicals or dietary
proteins. This process begins in the gastrointestinal tract but manifests
itself in the brain (FIG. 1). These factors will be explained in detail in
the following sections.
An embodiment provides for a method for determining etiology of an
autistic spectrum disorder in a patient, comprising the steps of: a)
determining a level of at least one infectious agent derived antigen or
antibody against an infectious agent derived antigen, at least one toxic
chemical derived antigen or an antibody against a toxic chemical, and at
least one dietary protein derived antigen or antibody against a dietary
protein, in one or more samples from the patient; b) comparing the level
of antigens and/or antibodies determined in step a) with a normal level of
the antigens and/or antibodies from control subjects, wherein (i) normal
level or lower than normal level of antigens and/or antibodies for the
each of said antigens indicate absence of an etiology of autistic spectrum
disorder from presence of said antigens; and (iii) higher than normal
level of antigens and/or antibodies for one or more of said antigens
and/or antibodies indicates a likelihood of the autistic spectrum disorder
being based on the presence of said antigens.
Another embodiment provides for a method for determining etiology of an
autistic spectrum disorder in a patient, comprising the steps of: a)
determining a level of antibodies to a self-tissue or peptide in one or
more samples from the patient; and b) comparing the level of antibodies
determined in step a) with a normal level of the antibodies from control
subjects, wherein (i) normal level or lower than normal levels of
antibodies indicate absence of etiology of autistic spectrum disorder from
presence of said antibodies; and (ii) higher than normal level of the
antibodies indicates a likelihood of the autistic spectrum disorder being
based on the presence of said antibodies. Preferably, the higher than
normal level of antibodies is calculated by taking a mean of levels of
antibodies in individuals without symptoms relating to autistic spectrum
disorder. Preferably, the higher than normal levels of antibodies is
higher than about two standard deviations of normal level of antibodies of
a control group.
Preferably, the determining the level of antibodies is accomplished using
an immunoassay, such as ELISA, RAST, dot blot, Western blot, and ELISPOT.
Preferably, the antibodies used in the immunoassay is selected from IgG,
IgA, or IgM.
As used herein, "autistic spectrum disorder" refers to a developmental
disorder that affects many aspects of a child's functioning. Autistic
spectrum disorder can include, but is not limited to, autism, pervasive
developmental disorder, and Asperger's Syndrome. Autistic spectrum
disorder can occur in combination with other disorders, such as Attention
Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) (which is part of the pervasive
developmental disorder), learning disabilities (LD), anxiety disorders,
obsessive-compulsive disorders (OCD), epilepsy, or mental retardation.
As used herein, "derived" or "derivative" refers to anything obtained or
deduced from another.
The Role of Infectious Agents in Autism
Many infectious agents, including Streptococcus, measles, Rubella,
Cytomegalovirus, Varicella zoster, Herpes type-6 and others have long been
suspected as etiologic factors in autism (2-4, 16-18). Maternal or
post-maternal exposure to these infectious agents may result in
neurological disorders including autism. Using the observation that
maternal infection increases the risk of schizophrenia anal autism in
offspring, recently it has been shown that respiratory infection of
pregnant mice (both BALB/c and C57BL/6 strains) with the human influenza
virus resulted in offspring that displayed highly abnormal behavioral
responses as adults. As in schizophrenia and autism, these offspring
displayed deficits in prepulse inhibition (PPI) in the acoustic startle
response. Compared with control mice, the infected mice also showed
striking responses to the acute administration of antipsychotic and
psychomimetic drugs. Moreover, these mice were deficient in exploratory
behavior in both open-field and novel-object tests, and they were
deficient in social interaction. At least some of these behavioral changes
were likely attributable to the maternal immune response itself. They
concluded that abnormal levels of cytokine production, which interfere
with neuroimmuno-communications, are responsible for abnormal development
of the brain (19-20).
Another explanation for disease development postulates that specific
antigenic epitopes from an unspecified infectious agent or agents induce(s)
a host immune response in which cross-reactivity with myelin triggers
disease, a concept referred to as molecular mimicry. In this scenario,
certain T-cells and/or antibodies elicited in response to antigens of the
infectious agent also recognize relevant self-antigens in the CNS, thereby
initiating the destructive autoimmune process (11-15, 21-27).
Infectious Agents and Response to Vaccinations
Many infectious agents, including measles, rubella virus and
Cytomegalovirus, Herpes Type-6 and anaerobe bacteria such as Clostridum
difficile have been implicated in autism. Therefore, the detection of
nucleic acids and antibodies in blood may indicate ongoing infection and
justify treatment with anti-bacterial or anti-viral agents (77-80).
Moreover, measurements of antibodies against measles, mumps, rubella (MMR),
diphtheria, pertusis, tetanus (DPT) and Hepatitis B will assess immune
response to immunization and production of protective antibodies. Moderate
elevation in IgG antibody against the components of MMR, DPT and Hepatitis
B vaccines indicate optimal immune response and good immunological memory
to these bacterial and viral antigens. High or very high levels of IgG
antibodies against antigenic components of the vaccines indicate
overactive immune response against them. Low levels or absence of IgG
antibodies against components of vaccines may indicate lack of
immunological memory and possibly immune deficiency in the immunized
individual.
Examples of antibodies associated with infectious agents and response to
vaccinations to be tested include, but are not limited to, measles, mumps,
rubella, diphtheria toxoid, pertussis, tetanus toxoid, hepatitis B, herpes
type 6, and clostridium neurotoxin.
The Role of Heavy Metals and Other Toxic Chemicals in Autism
Xenobiotics or toxic chemicals have been suspected to contribute to the
induction of autoimmunity (30-34). Many environmental chemicals or drugs
are toxic to hosts, and their detoxification is achieved primarily in the
liver. During their metabolism, they may form reactive metabolites, which
can then modify cellular proteins to form neoantigens. The precise
mechanisms that lead to modification of self-proteins and the molecular
requirements for this modified self to induce tolerance breakdown remain
to be established. However, it is important to note that the direct toxic
effect of xenobiotics is usually dose dependent and may be evident in the
majority of individuals shortly after drug intake; hence, they are
relatively easy to identify. In contrast, the immune-mediated effects that
follow the intake of drugs or xenobiotics may take a prolonged period of
time to be clinically manifest, making the identification of the causative
agents a formidable task (35).
Edelson and Cantor (5, 36) demonstrated that neurotoxicants play a
possible role in more than 90% of autistic children. These authors
presented evidence for genetic and environmental aspects of a proposed
process involving immune system injury and autoimmune responses secondary
to exposure to immunotoxins. They believe that activation of the immune
system is caused by toxicants leading to the production of autoantibodies
against haptens, i.e., the toxic chemicals attached to brain proteins. The
subsequent damage may be considered a component in the etiologic process
of neurotoxicity in the autistic spectrum.
For a chemical compound to lead to an autoimmune response, it is generally
thought that the compound must first become covalently bound to a carrier
protein (37, 39). Immune reactions to drugs or their metabolites can
develop when a hapten carrier complex interacts with gut-associated
lymphoid tissues (GALT) that constitute the largest lymphoid organ (38).
If covalent adducts of drugs or other chemical compounds are formed in
GALT, it seems reasonable that they may lead to immune responses and
chemically-induced Type I- Type IV allergic reactions (37). In fact, the
non-steroidal anti-inflammatory Dicoflenac has been shown to cause a
variety of idiosyncratic adverse reactions such as hemolytic anemia,
hepatotoxicity, agranulocytosis, and anaphylaxis, all of which are
components of immune reactions to protein adducts of Diclofenac (37-39).
These protein adducts can be formed by direct reaction with tissue
antigens or cytochrome P450 dependent and UDP-glucuronosyltransferase
dependent pathways of metabolism. For example, immunoblot analysis of
small intestine homogenates and isolated enterocytes with drug-specific
antiserum revealed protein adducts of diclofenac. Two of these adducts of
Diclofenac were identified as aminopeptidase N (CD 13) and
sucrase-isomaltase (38). Intestinal protein adducts of chemicals can,
therefore, be formed in GALT where they may lead to allergic reactions,
inflammation and autoimmunity.
Among many toxicants, such as thimerosal, merthiolate, ethyl mercury, or
other mercury-based compounds, in vaccines has been associated with immune
injuries described in children with autism (41-44). Contrary to many
haptens that bind covalently to a single amino acid, such as lysine, metal
complexes consist of a central metal ion composed of four different amino
acids, and hence they possess increased complex stability (37). To
demonstrate possible binding of ethyl mercury to DPP IV and CD69, we
postulated that in addition to infectious agent antigens such as
Streptokinase, ethyl mercury (xenobiotic) binds to different lymphocyte
receptors and tissue antigens. We assessed this hypothesis first by
measuring IgG, IgM and IgA antibodies against CD26, CD69 and SK against
ethyl mercury bound to human serum albumin in patients with autism. A
significant percentage of children with autism developed anti-SK, and
anti-ethyl mercury antibodies, concomitant with the appearance of
anti-CD26 and anti-CD69 autoantibodies. These antibodies are synthesized
as a result of SK and ethyl mercury binding to CD26 and CD69, indicating
that they are specific. Immune absorption demonstrated that only specific
antigens, like CD26, were capable of significantly reducing serum
anti-CD26 levels. However, for direct demonstration of SK and ethyl
mercury binding to CD26 or CD69, microtiter wells were coated with CD26 or
CD69 alone or in combination with SK or ethyl mercury and then reacted
with enzyme labeled rabbit anti-CD26 or anti-CD69. Adding these molecules
to cD26 or CD69 resulted in 28-86% inhibition of CD26 or CD69 binding to
anti-CD26 or anti-CD69 antibodies. We, therefore, propose that bacterial
antigens and thimerosal (ethyl mercury) in individuals with pre-disposing
HLA molecules, bind to CD26 or CD69 and induce antibodies against these
molecules as well as to lymphocyte receptors and tissue antigens,
resulting in autoimmune reaction in children with autism.
Neuroimmune Abnormalities Induced by Xenobiotics and Metals
It is of considerable interest that antibodies to neuron-specific antigens
are prevalent in populations exposed to environmental and occupational
chemicals and in patients with neurodegenerative diseases in which viruses
or other infectious agents are the suspected etiological agents. For
example, IgG antibodies to MBP, neuronal cytoskeletal proteins and
neurofilaments are detected in workers exposed to lead or mercury (45).
The titer of these antibodies is significantly correlated with blood lead
or urinary mercury, which are the typical indices of exposure. Moreover,
the level of these antibodies is correlated with the degree of
sensorimotor deficits, because these antibodies interfere with
neuromuscular function (46).
Taking into consideration the regulatory interactions between the nervous
system and the immune system, as well as the detection of MBP and NAFP
autoantibodies, it is therefore quite plausible to propose that drugs and
environmental toxins might have detrimental effects on neuroendocrine-immune
circuits, thereby resulting in autism. Toxic chemical exposure to
substances, such as polychlorinated biphenyl, mercury, lead and other
similar potentially harmful agents may induce alteration or
over-expression of the genes involved in regional brain glial fibrillary
acidic protein (GFAP) and astroglial glucose regulated protein (GRP). The
astroglial cytoskeletal element GFAP, neurotypic and gliotypic proteins or
neurofilament triplet are generally accepted as sensitive indicators of
neurotoxic effects in mature brains (47, 48).
Over-expression of the gene results in altering the structural
differentiation of astrocytes and the subsequent autoimmune response to
neurofilaments and astroglial glucose regulated proteins. Autoantibodies
against neurological antigens in autism have been studied in our
laboratory extensively and found to be elevated in children with autism
(11-15). The high prevalence of these autoantibodies in neurodegenerative
and neuropsychiatric disorders has led many investigators to believe that
these antibodies reflect an alteration of the blood-brain barrier, which
promotes the access of immunocompetent cells to the central nervous system
(49-52).
In these studies, we were able to present viable evidence in support of
the genetic and environmental aspects of a hypothetical process believed
to cause immune system injury secondary to immunotoxins exposure.
Activation of the immune system is caused by toxicants, leading to the
production of autoantibodies against haptens--the toxic chemicals attached
to brain proteins. The resulting damage may be considered a component in
the etiologic process of neurotoxicity in the autistic spectrum.
Autoimmune Reaction Induced by Heavy Metals
Mercury is a widely distributed environmental and industrial pollutant.
This is why methyl mercury is often detected in many fish. In fact,
ethyl-mercury or thimerosal has been used in increasing amounts as
preservatives in many vaccines since the 1950's. Therefore, during the
first year of life when the immune system is in the process of maturation,
children become exposed to up to 100 micrograms of mercury, which greatly
exceeds the CDC threshold. Exposure to large doses of mercury results in
acute renal tubular lesions and immunosuppression, whereas chronic
administration of smaller doses can lead to development of systemic
autoimmunity (31-34). The characteristic features of mercury-induced
autoimmunity are very similar to manifestations of SLE. This includes:
increased levels of Class II MHC antinuclear antibody production
hypergammaglobulinemia polyclonal antibody to self-antigens formation of
immune complexes lymphocyte proliferation necrotizing vasculitis
Mercury-induced autoimmunity is also similar to lupus in that the disease
process requires CD4+T-cells, T- and B-cell stimulatory molecules and
interferon-.gamma., which strongly suggests identical pathogenic
mechanisms. Given the complexity of metal, interaction with cellular and
subcellular components of the immune system and the large number of
molecules that may be affected, genetic studies were initiated to define
the genes responsible for sensitivity of resistance to mercury-induced
autoimmunity. A single major quantitative trait locus on chromosome 1,
designated as Hm.gamma.1 was linked to glomerular immune complex deposits
(81). Mercury is only one of a number of immunostimulatory heavy metal
xenobiotics that can induce adverse immunotoxicity. Several of these such
as silver or gold also promote the production of anti-fibrillarin
autoantibodies only in mercury-sensitive mouse stains (82).
Indeed after injection of methyl-mercury, a number of murine strains
develop an antibody response against U3 small nucleolar ribonucleo-proteins
called fibrillarin and chromatin. These antibodies have also been detected
in humans with scleroderma. Therefore, detection of anti-nuclear antibody
along with metals, fibrillarin and chromatin antibodies and elevation in
immune complexes indicate involvement of metals in induction of
inflammation and autoimmunity in autism (82). Further, production of these
antibodies may indicate a lack of functional metallothionein at cellular
level.
Examples of antibodies associated with autoimmune reaction and involvement
of metals to be tested include, but are not limited to, anti-nuclear
protein, mercury, fibrillarin, chromatin, immune complexes, and
metallothionein.
Neuroimmune Antibodies Induced by Dietary Proteins and Infectious Agents
As mentioned above, many infectious agents have long been suspected of
being etiologic factors in autism. Whether or not these viruses actually
induce brain autoantibodies has not yet been explored. For this reason, we
decided to review the available scientific literature and found that over
sixty different microbial peptides have been reported to cross-react with
human brain tissue and MBP. Furthermore, these peptides not only have the
capacity to cross-react with MBP and induce T-cell response, but also are
also able to induce experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (11, 26-30).
Among families with autistic children, it is well known that the
elimination of milk from the child's diet significantly improves the
patient's condition. Investigators found that an encephalitogenic T-cell
response to MOG can either be induced or alternatively suppressed as a
consequence of immunological cross-reactivity or molecular mimicry with
the extracellular IV-like domain of milk protein butyrophilin. All of
these clinical laboratory findings shed light on our detection of higher
levels of antibodies against milk antigens in autistic sera. Based on
earlier publications, we chose Streptococcus synthetic peptide containing
the conserved M protein or brain crossreactive epitope, a Chlamydia
pneumoniae-specific peptide and the butyrophilin milk peptide, which
modulates the encephalitogenic T-cell response to MOG in experimental
autoimmune encephalomyelitis for our cross-reactivity study (11, 65).
Detection of IgG, IgM and IgA antibodies against myelin basic protein,
neurofilaments and their cross-reactive epitopes in milk, Streptococcus
and Chlamydia may justify treatment with antibiotic and/or elimination
diet.
Examples of neuro-autoimmune antibodies induced by dietary proteins and
infectious agents and antibodies associated with the neuro-autoimmune
antibodies to be tested include, but are not limited to, myelin basic
protein, neurofilament, milk butyrophilin, streptococcus M protein, and
chlamydia pneumoniae.
Binding of Dietary Peptides to Different Tissue Enzymes May Promote
Development of Peptidase Antibodies in Children with Autism
Opioid peptides are available from a variety of food sources. These
dietary proteins and peptides, including casein, casomorphins, gluten (GLU)
and gluteomorphins, can stimulate T-cells, induce peptide-specific T-cell
responses, and abnormal levels of cytokine production, which may result in
inflammation, autoimmune reactions and disruption of neuroimmune
communications (54-57). In celiac disease (CD), a majority of patients who
express HLD-DQ2 and/or DQ8 react to a 33-mer peptide and 15 other T-cell
stimulatory peptides (58, 59). This peptide binding to HLA-DQ2 and HLA-DQ8
molecules is most efficient when negatively charged amino acids are
present at anchor positions in the peptide. Yet GLU contains very few
negatively charged amino acids, which makes GLU-derived peptides low
affinity ligands for HLA-DQ2 and -DQ8. This paradox has been solved by
finding that enzyme tissue transglutaminase, target of endomysium-specific
antibodies in CD patients, can modify GLU peptides by conversion of
glutamine residues into glutamic acid, which introduces negative charges
favored for binding (58-60).
A majority of children with autism cannot tolerate wheat and milk proteins
or peptides and hence elimination of these peptides from the diets
significantly improves their conditions. This clinical finding correlates
with laboratory results reported earlier by our group in children with
autism (11-15) and by different investigators in MS-like syndromes
(61-64). They found that an encephalitogenic T-cell response to myelin
oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) could be either induced or
alternatively suppressed as a consequence of immunological
cross-reactivity or "molecular mimicry" with the extra-cellular IV-like
domain of milk protein called butyrophilin (BTN) (65). We detected IgG,
IgM and IgA antibodies against nine specific neuron-specific antigens in
the sera of children with autism. These antibodies were found to bind with
different encephalitogenic molecules that have sequence homologies to a
milk protein (11).
Indeed, when we tested IgG, IgM and IgA antibodies against milk peptides,
we found that every single serum with ELISA values higher than 0.3 O.D.
against neurological antigens also exhibited high levels of antibodies
against neurological antigens and antibodies against milk peptides in a
higher percentage of experimental sera. Similar to milk peptides,
antibodies against different gliadin peptides have also been described in
celiac disease and gluten ataxia (66-67).
Food Allergies and Intolerance
Food allergies may be said to be contributory to the behavioral disorders
of individuals inflicted in autism. Sensitivity to gluten and milk are
thought to be the major food allergens in these patients. In one study,
nineteen children with autistic syndromes were treated with either
gluten-free milk and milk-reduced diets, or milk-free and gluten-reduced
diets. Before treatment, five of the fifteen fully studied patients had
increased levels of IgA antibodies to casein or gluten. After following
the diet for a year, improvement was noted in terms of increased social
contact, decreased stereotypy, an end to self-mutilation (like head
banging), and a decrease in "dreamy state" periods. These improvements
were accompanied by a significant decrease in urinary peptide excretion.
The possible mechanism is that children with autism suffer from one or
more peptidase defects that fail to break down "exomorphins" (exogenous
opioids) found in milk and wheat. These exorphin peptides then gain entry
into the brain where they significantly disrupt brain chemistry (see FIGS.
2, 3).
The presence of other food allergies should also be determined, as food
allergies are likely the factor responsible for the increased intestinal
permeability noted in these patients. In fact, increased gut permeability
has been suggested as a possible causative factor for autism (73, 77).
Examples of antibodies associated with food allergy and intolerance to be
tested include, but are not limited to, milk, casomorphin, wheat gluten/gliadin,
gluteomorphin, corn, soy, and tissue enzyme, such as transglutaminase
which may modify resultant dietary peptides.
Cross-Reaction Between Gliadin and Cerebellar Purkinje Cells as a Possible
Mechanism for Neuroimmune Abnormalities in Autism
One of the most frequent presentations of gluten sensitivity is the
neurologic dysfunction called gluten ataxia. Up to 33% of patients
presenting with neurologic dysfunction and 90% of patients presenting with
pruritic vesicular rash of dermatitis herpetiformis associated with gluten
sensitivity also have celiac disease (66). While the remaining patients
have serologic markers or anti-gliadin antibodies and genetic
susceptibility (HLADQ2), they do not have histologic evidence of small
bowel involvement. Based on a major epidemiologic study involving more
than 200 patients, gluten ataxia was found to account for 40% of cases
with idiopathic sporadic cerebellar degeneration. When patients with
gluten ataxia were autopsied, perivascular cuffing with inflammatory
cells, predominantly affecting the cerebellum, and loss of Purkinje cells
were detected. These inflammatory reactions resulting in Purkinje cell
loss imply that the neurologic insult may be immune-mediated (67, 69, 70).
It is not clear whether such immune-mediated damage is primarily cellular
or antibody-driven. In a recent study, investigators assessed the
reactivity of sera from patients with gluten ataxia, patients newly
diagnosed with celiac disease without neurologic dysfunction and healthy
control subjects (67).
Using indirect immunocytochemisty on human cerebellar and rat CNS tissue,
cross-reactivity of a commercial IgA antigliadin antibody with cerebellar
tissue was analyzed. Sera from 12 of 13 patients with gluten ataxia
strongly presented stained Purkinje cells. Less intense staining was
observed in some but not all sera from patients with newly diagnosed
celiac disease without neurologic dysfunction. At high dilutions (1:800)
staining was observed only using sera from patients with gluten, ataxia
but not from control subjects. Sera from patients with gluten ataxia also
stained some brainstem and cortical neurons in rat CNS tissue. Commercial
anti-gliadin antibody stained human Purkinje cells' in a similar manner.
Absorption of the antigliadin antibodies using crude gliadin abolished the
staining in patients with celiac disease without neurologic dysfunction,
but not in those with gluten ataxia. The conclusion suggested that
patients with gluten ataxia have antibodies against Purkinje cells that
cross-react with epitopes on Purkinje cells, and humoral immune responses
are involved in the pathogenesis of gluten ataxia (67).
Direct Evidence for Structural Similarity Between Gliadin Peptides and
Cerebellar Antigens
Several distinctive neurologic disorders occur in patients with
paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration (PCD). The syndrome of PCD is among
the most common of these disorders and generally occurs in patients with
neoplasms of the lung, breast, ovary, or with Hodgkin's disease.
Neuropathologic features of PCD include extensive loss of Purkinje cells,
degenerative changes in the remaining Purkinje cells, as well as variable
losses of granule and basket neurons.
The presence of anti-Purkinje cell antibodies in some PCD patients
suggests an autoimmune etiology. To identify the molecular targets for
these autoantibodies, an Agt11 cDNA expression library from human
cerebellum was constructed and screened with IgG from a patient with
paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration. A single clone, pCDR2, produced a
fusion protein that reacted strongly with the patient's IgG. Sequencing
the pCDR clones revealed 6 amino acids repeated in tandem along the entire
cDNA sequence (VAL, PRO, LEU, LEU, GLU, ASP). (SEQ ID NO: 4). This gene
was expressed predominantly in neuroectodermal tissues (68).
Neurotransmitters and Neuroimmune Miscommunication
Autism was originally thought to be primarily a psychiatric condition.
However, recent biochemical genetic studies have lead to the hypothesis
that the disorder is due to an organic defect in brain development.
Specifically, autism is thought to be a result of abnormal serotonin
metabolism in the brain. The abnormalities that have been documented
include:
abnormal release and uptake of serotonin by platelets
abnormal kynurenine metabolism
increased serum serotonin and free tryptophan levels
abnormal urinary 5-hydroxyindolacetic acid (5-HIAA) levels
abnormal urinary Serotonin metabolites
The basic defect appears to be a decrease in CNS Serotonin activity
despite elevated free tryptophan levels in the serum. Abnormal serotonin
metabolites seen in autistic children may significantly contribute to
their mental dysfunction (83-85). Drugs such as LSD, psilocybin, ergot,
and other hallucinogens are serotonin analogs, and a number of serotonin
metabolites are known to be hallucinogens. It is also interesting to note
that serotonin and its metabolites are produced in, and absorbed from, the
intestines.
This abnormal level of serotonin along with reaction of bacterial toxins,
xenobiotics and dietary peptides with different aminopeptidases and gut-neuroimmune
communications results in autoantibody production against these important
tissue enzymes such as somatostatin, vasoactive intestinal peptides.
Formation of antibodies against peptidases results in dysfunctional
enzymes and accumulation of peptides in the GI tract and in circulation.
These dietary peptides in the blood may bind to G protein receptors, cause
immune dysfunction and transmigrate across blood, the blood-brain barrier,
and activate the local antigen-presenting cells, such as microglia and
astrocytes. By reacting to .mu., .gamma., .kappa. opioid receptors on both
lymphocytes and nerve cells, dietary peptides such as pro-dynorphins,
dynorphins, casomorphins and gluteomorphins may change the level of
cytokine and interfere with neuroimmune communication. Therefore,
detection of high or low levels of serotonin along with antibodies to
serotonin, somatostatin, vasoactive intestinal peptides, DPP IV, pro-dynorphin
and dynorphin may indicate disturbance in gut-neuroimmune communication.
Examples of antibodies associated with neurotransmitters and neuroimmune
miscommunication to be tested include, but are not limited to, serotonin
receptor antibodies, serotonin antibodies, somatostatin antibodies,
vasoactive intestinal peptide, prodynorphin, dynorphin, and
dipeptidylpeptidase IV.
Pathogenesis and Mechanism of Autoimmunity and Autism
For cross-reactive circulating antibodies to become pathogenic, they must
cross the blood-brain barrier. It is now known that permeability of the
blood-brain barrier increases after major histocompatibility complex class
I expression (Fabry et al, 1994), activated lymphocyte interaction, and
change in neuronal cell adhesion molecules (71, 72). Based on review of
literature and results reported here, we propose the following chain of
events, as shown in FIG. 4, that may explain possible mechanisms of injury
in autism: 1. In the course of a lifetime, the body is exposed to
infectious agents, which mimic neuron-specific antigens, such as EBV, CMV,
HHV-6, HTLV-1, HTLV-2, streptococcus, Chlamydia pneumoniae or even milk
and gluten peptides. 2. Pre-existing auto-reactive T-cells are generated
by molecular mimicry as a result of contact with dietary proteins and
viral, bacterial, and parasitic antigens, which have sequence homologies
or matched motifs with auto antigens. 3. Bacterial enterotoxins, viral
antigens, and metals, such as mercury and lead, may increase adhesion
molecules on brain endothelial cells. Toxic chemicals may also increase
leukocyte function-associated antigens on activated T-cells. 4.
Pre-existing autoreactive T-cells may transmigrate across the blood-brain
barrier and induce the activation of local antigen-presenting cells, such
as microglia and astrocytes. 5. By reacting to .mu., .gamma., and .kappa.
opioid receptors on both lymphocytes and nerve cells, dietary peptides
such as casomorphins, gluteomorphins and others may change the level of
cytokine production and interfere with neuroimmune communication (19, 20,
53; FIGS. 2, 3). 6. This neuroimmune miscommunication may result in
production of IL-2, INF-.gamma. and TNF-.alpha. by T-helper-I autoreactive
cells and TNF-.alpha. by the antigen presenting cells (astrocytes and
microglia may result in oligodendrocyte damage and demyelination). 7. As a
result of this sequence of events, MBP, MAG, MOG, .alpha., .beta.-crystallin
and other antigens are released from neurofilaments and enter the
circulatory system. This results in immune reactions, such as the
formation of plasma cells with the capacity of producing IgG, IgM and IgA
antibodies against neuron-specific antigens. 8. These antibodies may cross
the blood-brain barrier and combine with brain tissue antigens to form
immune complexes, thus causing further damage to the neurological tissue.
The antibodies, along with toxic biological weaponry, such as arachidonic
acid and free radicals, can "chew off" neuron myelin and impair electrical
transmission between a muscle and the central nervous system. 9. This
hypothesis may explain significant differences in levels of pathogenic
autoantibodies between control subjects and patients exposed to toxic
chemicals and metals (11, 15, 19, 20, 53).
An embodiment provides for a method for determining etiology of an
autistic spectrum disorder in a patient, comprising the steps of: a)
determining a level of at least one infectious agent derived antigen or
antibody against an infectious agent derived antigen, at least one toxic
chemical derived antigen or an antibody against a toxic chemical, and at
least one dietary protein derived antigen or antibody against a dietary
protein, in one or more samples from the patient; b) comparing the level
of antigens and/or antibodies determined in step a) with a normal level of
the antigens and/or antibodies from control subjects, wherein (i) normal
level or lower than normal level of antigens and/or antibodies for the
each of said antigens indicate absence of an etiology of autistic spectrum
disorder from presence of said antigens; and (iv) higher than normal level
of antigens and/or antibodies for one or more of said antigens and/or
antibodies indicates a likelihood of the autistic spectrum disorder being
based on the presence of said antigens.
Another embodiment provides for a method for determining etiology of an
autistic spectrum disorder in a patient, comprising the steps of: a)
determining a level of antibodies to a self-tissue or peptide in one or
more samples from the patient; and b) comparing the level of antibodies
determined in step a) with a normal level of the antibodies from control
subjects, wherein (i) normal level or lower than normal levels of
antibodies indicate absence of etiology of autistic spectrum disorder from
presence of said antibodies; and (ii) higher than normal level of the
antibodies indicates a likelihood of the autistic spectrum disorder being
based on the presence of said antibodies.
Preferred self-tissue or peptide include, but is not limited to, tissue
and cell antigens, receptors, mediators, enzymes, and neurotransmitters.
More specifically, preferred self-tissue or peptide include, but is not
limited to, digestive enzymes (pepsin, trypsin, chymotrypsin),
aminopeptidase, dipeptidyl peptidase, CD26, DPPI IV, CD13, CD69,
transglutaminase, epithelial cells, brush border antigens and enzymes,
colon tissue antigens, gastrin, gastrin inhibitory polypeptide, secretin,
motilin, enkephelin, substance P, somatostatin, and serotonin. When a
preferred self-tissue antigen or peptide is a neurotransmitter or a
neurotransmitter receptor, the preferred self-tissue antigen or peptide is
selected from the group consisting of serotonin receptor, serotonin,
somatostatin, vasoactive intestinal peptide, pro-dynorphin, dynorphin,
dipeptidylpeptidase IV, and complex dipeptidylpeptidase IV.
Claim 1 of 7 Claims
1. A method for diagnosing an autistic
spectrum disorder in a patient, comprising the steps of: a) determining a
level of antibodies to a protein selected from the group consisting of an
aminopeptidase N (CD13), dipeptidyl peptidase IV (CD26), dipeptidyl
peptidase I and CD69, in one or more samples from the patient; and b)
comparing the level of antibodies determined in step a) with a normal
level of the antibodies from control subjects, wherein (i) normal level or
lower than normal levels of antibodies indicate absence of autistic
spectrum disorder in said patient; and (ii) higher than normal level of
the antibodies indicates the presence of the autistic spectrum disorder in
said patient.
____________________________________________
If you want to learn more
about this patent, please go directly to the U.S.
Patent and Trademark Office Web site to access the full
patent.
|