|
|
Title: Agents for treatment of
HCV and methods of use
United States Patent: 7,326,536
Issued: February 5, 2008
Inventors: Glenn; Jeffrey
S. (Palo Alto, CA), Myers; Tina Marie (Indianapolis, IN), Glass; John
Irvin (Germantown, MD)
Assignee: Eli Lilly and
Company (Indianapolis, IN), The Board of Trustees of the Leland Stanford
Junior University (Palo Alto, CA)
Appl. No.: 10/481,261
Filed: May 3, 2002
PCT Filed: May 03, 2002
PCT No.: PCT/US02/13951
371(c)(1),(2),(4) Date:
July 30, 2004
PCT Pub. No.: WO02/089731
PCT Pub. Date: November 14,
2002
|
|
|
Executive MBA in Pharmaceutical Management, U. Colorado
|
Abstract
An amphipathic helix at the approximate
N-terminus of Hepatitis C virus (HCV) nonstructural proteins mediates the
association of these proteins with cytoplasmic membranes in infected
cells. This association is essential for replication. Thus, assessing the
ability of compounds or protocols to disrupt the association of such
helices with cytoplasmic membranes permits identification of compounds and
protocols which are useful in the treatment of HCV infection. Also useful
in the invention are mimics, or function-disrupting ligands, of an
amphipathic helix of the nonstructural proteins described herein and
antibodies and fragments thereof immunoreactive with said helix.
Description of the
Invention
The Hepatitis C virus has been
well studied and the genome has been completely sequenced. The genome of HCV
is a single-stranded RNA of 9.6 kb that encodes a single approximately 3,010
amino acid polyprotein. This polyprotein is proteolytically processed into
structural proteins and nonstructural proteins. HCV, like other positive
strand RNA viruses, is thought to replicate in association with cytoplasmic
membranes; and the approximately 447 amino acid nonstructural protein, NS5A
is known to associate with host cell membranes. This protein is thus
believed to play a key role in replication. The discovery of alternative
treatments has been hampered by the lack of a cell culture model for HCV.
The present invention overcomes this problem, and provides a convenient
assay for identifying agents that can directly and specifically curtail the
course of HCV infection. As noted above, the present invention resides in
the discovery of a mechanism to disrupt association between certain
nonstructural proteins of the virus and cytoplasmic membranes.
Administration of peptides and proteins intracellularly has been limited by
the lack of consistent and efficient uptake across the cell membrane.
However, various membrane translocation sequences (MTS) have been identified
which allow the transduction of peptides across the plasma membrane (for
example, References 10, 13, 14, 16, 17, 20, 21 and 22). While unknown, it is
hypothesized that the mechanism of the transduction is that an MTS is able
to transport both peptides and full-length proteins into the cytoplasm of
cells. It is believed that the separate peptides form a noncovalent complex
in solution that is then transported into the cell.
It has now been found that an amphipathic helix consisting of about 20-25
amino acids is critical to the association of NS5A with cytoplasmic
membranes, for example endoplasmic reticulum (ER), as are similar helices
found in NS4B and NS5B. As shown below, when the amphipathic nature of the
helix is disrupted, NS5A no longer associates with cell membranes; in
addition, the helix when coupled to other substances, including other
proteins, effects association of the carried component to the cell's
cytoplasmic membranes. As used herein, "cytoplasmic membrane" refers to a
structure contained in the cellular cytoplasm, which can generally be
recognized as a membrane structure for example, membranes of the endoplasmic
reticulum (ER). The membranes may include protein receptors or other
elements in addition to the more hydrophobic portions of the membrane per se
which may account at least in part for the association of the amphipathic
helix to the "cytoplasmic membrane". No theory is advanced as to the
mechanism whereby the amphipathic helix associates itself with the
cytoplasmic membrane, and thus the precise elements contained in the
membrane, which are responsible for this association, are not defined. The
observations related to the screening methods described below are not
dependent on any definition: intracellular embodiments of these assays rely
on direct observation of the cellular distribution of the helix and its
label and studies which involve membrane preparations ex vivo employ
compositions of cytoplasmic membranes as conventionally prepared, without
regard to substructure. This amphipathic helix feature is found in
nonstructural proteins of isolates of many strains of HCV of various
geographical origins. It is also demonstrated below that disruption of the
amphipathic nature of the helix of NS5A prevents replication of HCV RNA.
FIG. 1 (see Original Patent) shows the amino acid sequences of the
amphipathic helices that have been found near to the N-terminus of three
nonstructural proteins from prototype genotype 1a representing amino acids
7-34 of NS4B (SEQ ID NO: 1), amino acids 5-26 of NS5A (SEQ ID NO: 2), and
two amphipathic helical regions of NS5B, amino acids 65-87 (SEQ ID NO: 3)
and 107-125 (SEQ ID NO: 4). This figure also shows the relevant sequences in
NS5A for additional genotypes 1b (acc. No. P26663) (SEQ ID NO: 5); 2a (acc.
No. P26660) (SEQ ID NO: 6); 2b (acc. No. AB030907) (SEQ ID NO: 7); 3a-K
(acc. No. D28917) (SEQ ID NO: 8); 3a-NZL (acc. No. D17763) (SEQ ID NO: 9);
3b (acc. No. D49374) (SEQ ID NO: 10); 4a (acc. No. Y11604) (SEQ ID NO: 11);
10a (acc. No. D63821) (SEQ ID NO: 12); and 11a (acc. No. D63822) (SEQ ID NO:
13). The sequences listed in FIG. 1 are not an exhaustive list of the amino
acid sequences of amphipathic helices of these three nonstructural proteins.
NS4B and NS5B may be expanded similarly to NS4A in FIG. 1. Although the
sequences per se are not completely homologous, they are all capable of
forming amphipathic helices. (See FIGS. 2A-2J (see Original Patent) which
show these helices from the NS5A proteins.) Thus, it is clear that the
presence of the N-terminal amphipathic helix, containing a sequence of
approximately 20-25 amino acids is widespread in the nonstructural proteins
of HCV and in various isolates.
As used herein, the term "HCV nonstructural protein amphipathic helix"
refers to a sequence of at least 15 amino acids, preferably at least 20
amino acids and preferably not more than 30, more preferably not more than
25 amino acids which has the amino acid sequence selected from the group
consisting of those set forth in FIG. 1, or which is at least 80%
homologous, preferably at least 90% homologous and more preferably at least
95% homologous to at least one of said sequences and which retains the
ability to form an amphipathic helix. While it is known that certain amino
acid substitutions will result in peptides, which, while they retain the
required degree of homology (sequence identity), will disrupt the formation
of the helix, the nature of these substitutions is already understood by
those of ordinary skill and can be avoided, or purposefully used, as
desired. Insertion of, for example, disruptive proline residues, is
understood to be undesirable. Thus, it is well within ordinary skill to
substitute one or more amino acids in these sequences to obtain substitute
helices with the required degree or homology, avoiding unsuccessful
substitutions.
It should be noted that in certain embodiments of the invention, the
amphipathic helix may be other than a peptide; for example, it may
constitute a pseudopeptide where the native peptide linkages are substituted
by isosteres as is understood in the art. Similarly, alternative polymeric
structures can be designed which mimic the charge and shape distribution of
these amphipathic helices and mutants and variants thereof. These homologs
and analogs are included within the scope of the invention and are useful
both in therapeutic protocols and in assay systems for ascertaining
alternative compounds and protocols which will be useful in treating HCV
infection.
As used herein, the term "amino acid" is applicable not only to cell
membrane-permeant peptides, but also to amphipathic helices and anti-HCV
peptides useful as pharmaceutical agents, i.e., all the individual
components of the present compositions.
The term "amino acid" is used herein in its broadest sense, and includes
naturally occurring amino acids as well as non-naturally occurring amino
acids, including amino acid analogs and derivatives. The latter includes
molecules containing an amino acid moiety. One skilled in the art will
recognize, in view of this broad definition, that reference herein to an
amino acid includes, for example, naturally occurring proteogenic L-amino
acids; D-amino acids; chemically modified amino acids such as amino acid
analogs and derivatives; naturally occurring non-proteogenic amino acids
such as norleucine, .beta.-alanine, ornithine, etc.; and chemically
synthesized compounds having properties known in the art to be
characteristic of amino acids. As used herein, the term "proteogenic"
indicates that the amino acid can be incorporated into a peptide,
polypeptide, or protein in a cell through a metabolic pathway.
The incorporation of non-natural amino acids, including synthetic non-native
amino acids, substituted amino acids, or one or more D-amino acids into the
present anti-HCV peptides of the present invention is advantageous in a
number of different ways. D-amino acid-containing peptides exhibit increased
stability in vitro or in vivo compared to L-amino acid-containing
counterparts. Thus, the construction of peptides incorporating D-amino acids
can be particularly useful when greater intracellular stability is desired
or required. More specifically, D-peptides, etc., are resistant to
endogenous peptidases and proteases, thereby providing improved
bioavailability of the molecule, and prolonged lifetimes in vivo when such
properties are desirable. When it is desirable to allow the peptide, etc.,
to remain active for only a short period of time, the use of L-amino acids
therein will permit endogenous peptidases, proteases, etc., in a cell to
digest the molecule in vivo, thereby limiting the cell's exposure to the
molecule. Additionally, D-peptides, etc., cannot be processed efficiently
for major histocompatibility complex class II-restricted presentation to T
helper cells, and are therefore less likely to induce humoral immune
responses in the whole organism.
One factor that can be considered in making such changes is the hydropathic
index of amino acids. The importance of the hydropathic amino acid index in
conferring interactive biological function on a protein has been discussed
by Kyte and Doolittle (1982, J. Mol. Biol., 157: 105-132). It is accepted
that the relative hydropathic character of amino acids contributes to the
secondary structure of the resultant protein. This, in turn, affects the
interaction of the protein with molecules such as enzymes, substrates,
receptors, DNA, antibodies, antigens, etc.
Based on its hydrophobicity and charge characteristics, each amino acid has
been assigned a hydropathic index as follows: isoleucine (+4.5); valine
(+4.2); leucine (+3.8); phenylalanine (+2.8); cysteine/cystine (+2.5);
methionine (+1.9); alanine (+1.8); glycine (-0.4); threonine (-0.7); serine
(-0.8); tryptophan (-0.9); tyrosine (-1.3); proline (-1.6); histidine
(-3.2); glutamate/glutamine/aspartate/asparagine (-3.5); lysine (-3.9); and
arginine (-4.5).
As is known in the art, certain amino acids in a peptide, polypeptide, or
protein can be substituted for other amino acids having a similar
hydropathic index or score and produce a resultant peptide, etc., having
similar biological activity, i.e., which still retains biological
functionality. In making such changes, it is preferable that amino acids
having hydropathic indices within .+-.2 are substituted for one another.
More preferred substitutions are those wherein the amino acids have
hydropathic indices within .+-.1. Most preferred substitutions are those
wherein the amino acids have hydropathic indices within .+-.0.5.
Like amino acids can also be substituted on the basis of hydrophilicity.
U.S. Pat. No. 4,554,101, herein incorporated by reference, discloses that
the greatest local average hydrophilicity of a protein, as governed by the
hydrophilicity of its adjacent amino acids, correlates with a biological
property of the protein. The following hydrophilicity values have been
assigned to amino acids: arginine/lysine (+3.0); aspartate/glutamate
(+3.0.+-.1); serine (+0.3); asparagine/glutamine (+0.2); glycine (0);
threonine (-0.4); proline (-0.5.+-.1); alanine/histidine (-0.5); cysteine
(-1.0); methionine (-1.3); valine (-1.5); leucine/isoleucine (-1.8);
tyrosine (-2.3); phenylalanine (-2.5); and tryptophan (-3.4). Thus, one
amino acid in a peptide, polypeptide, or protein can be substituted by
another amino acid having a similar hydrophilicity score and still produce a
resultant peptide, etc., having similar biological activity, i.e., still
retaining correct biological function. In making such changes, amino acids
having hydropathic indices within .+-.2 are preferably substituted for one
another, those within .+-.1 are more preferred, and those within .+-.0.5 are
most preferred.
As outlined above, amino acid substitutions in the anti-HCV peptides of the
present invention can be based on the relative similarity of the amino acid
side-chain substituents, for example, their hydrophobicity, hydrophilicity,
charge, size, etc. Exemplary substitutions that take various of the
foregoing characteristics into consideration in order to produce
conservative amino acid changes resulting in silent changes within the
present peptides, etc., can be selected from other members of the class to
which the naturally occurring amino acid belongs. Amino acids can be divided
into the following four groups: (1) acidic amino acids; (2) basic amino
acids; (3) neutral polar amino acids; and (4) neutral non-polar amino acids.
Representative amino acids within these various groups include, but are not
limited to: (1) acidic (negatively charged) amino acids such as aspartic
acid and glutamic acid; (2) basic (positively charged) amino acids such as
arginine, histidine, and lysine; (3) neutral polar amino acids such as
glycine, serine, threonine, cysteine, cystine, tyrosine, asparagine, and
glutamine; and (4) neutral non-polar amino acids such as alanine, leucine,
isoleucine, valine, proline, phenylalanine, tryptophan, and methionine.
It should be noted that changes which are not expected to be advantageous
can also be useful if these result in the production of functional
sequences. Since small peptides, etc., can be easily produced by
conventional solid phase synthetic techniques, the present invention
includes peptides, etc., such as those discussed herein, containing the
amino acid modifications discussed above, alone or in various combinations.
To the extent that such modifications can be made while substantially
retaining the activity of the peptide, they are included within the scope of
the present invention. The utility of such modified peptides, etc., can be
determined without undue experimentation by, for example, the methods
described herein.
Based on the present discoveries, various methods to identify agents and
protocols which would be effective in treating HCV are made possible. In
their simplest form, since binding between the helix and the cytoplasmic
membrane is a necessary condition for association of the nonstructural
protein with the membrane and is required for the virus to replicate,
compounds which simply bind the helix compete with the cellular membranes
for this association. When the helix is contained in a substantially larger
molecule, such as existing in the context of a significantly longer amino
acid sequence, it is possible that the remaining portion of the molecule or
amino acid sequence may itself contain elements that are capable of
affecting binding. Thus, in the assays of the invention, appropriate
controls may be required to ensure that it is the interaction of the helix
with the compounds tested or the membranes tested that is being measured.
Compounds that bind to the helix would inhibit the required cellular
binding, and by identifying compounds that bind with high affinity to the
helix compounds that would be successful in interfering with the binding
will be found. By "high affinity" is meant binding with a dissociation
constant of <10.sup.-4, preferably <10.sup.-6, and more preferably
<10.sup.-8. Dissociation constants can be determined using methods generally
known in the art; for example the helix could be bound to solid support and
labeled compound at varying concentrations supplied wherein the amount of
label coupled to solid support can be readily determined.
Alternatively, the peptide comprising the helix can be displayed using
standard phage display techniques and the phage tested for ability to bind
to compounds that are coupled to solid supports. Phage display is also
utilized to screen random peptides to screen for competitive inhibitors of
the amphipathic helix. Such peptides would block virus from binding to the
receptor.
There are a variety of techniques well known in the art for assessing
binding of compounds to targets. A wide variety of detectable labels can be
used, and the assays can be conducted in heterogeneous or homogeneous
formats. For example, the compound itself can be labeled for detection of
its ability to transport label to solid support, to which solid support has
been bound the amphipathic helix or, vice versa, the amphipathic helix can
be labeled and the compound to be tested can be coupled to solid support.
The assay can also be conducted in a homogeneous format using fluorescence
techniques, for example, where the fluorescence of a fluorescent label
attached to the compound is altered by virtue of its binding to a peptide
the size of the amphipathic helix or larger.
The amphipathic helix itself can be supplied in the context of the
nonstructural protein or fragment thereof or can be supplied per se or as a
fusion protein that contains a label, such as green fluorescent protein.
In a variation of this extracellular format, the effect of individual
compounds or mixtures of compounds on the binding of the amphipathic helix
or a protein containing it with a membrane preparation can be evaluated.
Techniques similar to those described above may be used--e.g., the membrane
preparation may be labeled and the amphipathic helix or protein containing
it coupled to solid support or displayed using phage. The coupling of the
label to solid support containing the helix or relevant protein or to the
phage displayed helix in the presence and absence of compound or mixtures of
compounds can be determined. These assays can be conducted in homogeneous
format by using fluorescence labeling, for example, of the amphipathic
helix. A wide variety of such protocols is known in the art, and the
essential feature is determination of the effect of the compound or a
mixture of compounds on the binding of the amphipathic helix or a protein
containing it and the membrane preparation. Perhaps a particularly
convenient embodiment of this method would involve a fusion between the
amphipathic helix and green fluorescent protein which could be produced very
conveniently using recombinant techniques; assessment of the binding of this
fusion to the membrane preparation either in a heterogeneous or homogeneous
format can then be performed.
As further described below, in Example 3, an assay for binding of the
amphipathic helix to the microsomal membrane can be performed by treating a
microsomal or cytoplasmic membrane preparation in vitro with a peptide
containing the helix and distributing the contents of the reaction mixture
in a sedimentation gradient. The helix coupled to membrane will reside in a
relatively low density portion of the gradient and is thus separated from
mere debris that is found at the bottom of the gradient. The floated helix
can be detected in the appropriate gradient fraction using polyacrylamide
gel electrophoresis. The helix may be labeled for example, with a
radioisotope or a coupled fluorescent label such as green fluorescent
protein used in a fusion. This assay can be used to screen for compounds or
protocols that disrupt binding to the microsomal membrane by conducting the
assay in the presence and absence of the protocols or compounds and
comparing the results.
In addition to the above-described methods that can be conducted
extracellularly, the effect of various protocols and compounds or mixtures
of compounds on the behavior in terms of binding to cytoplasmic membranes of
the relevant amphipathic helix can be determined in a variety of
intracellular assays. Any eukaryotic cells may be used, but typically and
most conveniently, mammalian cells or yeast cells are used in these assays.
Intracellular assays can be performed by generating desired peptide
constructs intracellularly from recombinant expression systems.
Alternatively, the assays can be conducted by first preparing the labeled
amphipathic helix or protein containing said helix and introducing the
derivatized helix into the cells using cell-penetrating peptides. The
compounds to be tested may be introduced in the same manner. Such
cell-penetrating peptides are described, for example, in a review article by
Lindgrin, M., et al., in TiPS (2000) 21:99-103, the contents of which are
incorporated herein by reference to describe an exemplary list of such
cell-penetrating peptides. These peptides can be coupled to any substance to
facilitate the entry of said substance into a eukaryotic cell.
In another embodiment, MTS is able to transport both peptides and
full-length proteins into the cytoplasm of cells with or without covalent
linkage or crosslinking. (For example, Reference 14.) It is believed that
the separate peptides form a noncovalent complex in solution that is then
transported into the cell. In one embodiment, the peptides are NS4B or NS5A.
The ability to deliver peptides and proteins into the intracellular milieu
for investigational studies or therapeutic applications has previously been
limited by the lack of consistent and efficient uptake across the cell
membrane. However, a number of reports in the last couple of years have
identified various membrane translocation sequences (For example, see
references 10, 13, 14, 16, 17, 20, 21, 22) that allow the transduction of
peptides across the plasma membrane. The mechanism of transduction is not
yet clear, but it has been shown that it is not due to receptor-mediated
uptake, or in conjunction with a known transport mechanism. In the initial
reports, the MTS was covalently linked to the peptide or protein that was to
be delivered into the cell, but recently an MTS was identified that was able
to transport both peptides and full-length proteins into the cytoplasm of
cells in the absence of covalent linkage or crosslinking (14). Apparently,
the separate peptides form a noncovalent complex in solution that is then
transported into the cell.
In the most direct forms of such assays, the change in intracellular
distribution of the labeled amphipathic helix either supplied per se or in
the context of a larger protein can be determined. A wide variety of labels
can be used; perhaps the most convenient is a fusion with green fluorescent
protein, or simple coupling of the amphipathic helix or the protein
containing it to a detectable fluorescent label. The location of the labeled
helix or protein containing it can then be observed by a variety of methods
including direct observation and histological techniques. Thus, in one
example, the effect of a candidate compound or protocol directly on the
ability of the helix to bind to cellular membranes can be assessed by
coupling the helix to a reporter which is detectable; most convenient are
labels which are fusion proteins formed with the helix, such as green
fluorescent protein. The intracellular locations of the reporter in the
presence and absence of the candidate protocol compound can then be
compared. The corresponding labeled helix, which has been mutated to disrupt
the amphipathic helical conformation, can conveniently be used as a control.
Compounds or protocols that are able to disrupt the binding of the helix
with the membrane can readily be identified when their presence results in
less label associated with cell membranes.
If histological techniques are used, the label can be less direct; for
example, the helix might be fused to a protein that can be detected with a
labeled antibody or may be fused to an enzyme that can be detected in the
presence of a substrate. Once the cells are fixed histologically, the
supplementary reagents can be added for detection.
Another embodiment of this uses cells harboring a vector or plasmid
expression NS5A or HCV replicon with a wild-type amphipathic helix in NS5A.
The cells are exposed to a control or candidate inhibitor. At the end of the
assay, the cells are fixed and stained for NS5A by indirect
immunofluorescence. A compound is deemed inhibitory if it alters the normal
membrane associated staining of NS5A.
Test compounds that appear to interrupt the ability of the amphipathic helix
to bind to the cellular membranes, or which are shown to disrupt the normal
binding pattern of the amphipathic helix can be confirmed as anti-HCV agents
in a standard colony formation assay. In this assay, an HCV replicon is
supplied with a drug resistance marker, such as neomycin resistance. When
neomycin-sensitive cells are infected with the replicon and grown on
neomycin-containing medium or G418, for example, only cells wherein
replication can occur will be able to form colonies. The diagnostic replicon
can be used to infect neomycin-sensitive cells in the presence and absence
of the compound that has been shown to disrupt the amphipathic
helix/membrane binding, and such compounds result in destroying or
decreasing the ability of the infected cells to form colonies.
Alternatively, RNA replicon levels can be measured to identify the effect of
the compound.
When intracellular formats are used, in addition to testing compounds and
mixtures of compounds, as noted above, it is possible to test the effect of
protocols which involve various regimes of treatment, including, in addition
to providing compounds, various antisense techniques, and various forms of
environmental stress such as pH changes, temperature changes, mechanical
disturbances and the like.
In addition to the foregoing, somewhat more sophisticated methods to assess
the impact of compounds and protocols on the intracellular location of
substances containing the amphipathic helices derived from Hepatitis C
nonstructural proteins can be employed. For example, it is demonstrated
below that disruption of the amphipathic helix in NS5A, in addition to
causing the protein to fail to associate with cytoplasmic membranes, directs
this protein to the nucleus. Therefore, the assay methods can include
features in the substance containing the amphipathic helix that act as
nuclear localization signals (NLS), many of which are well known in the art.
Under these conditions the label can constitute a functionality which exerts
its effect in the nucleus, and the disruption of binding of the amphipathic
helix with the cytoplasmic membrane can be detected by a reporter function
associated with the helix which exerts its effects in the nucleus. Such
effects would be, for example, enhancement or repression of the expression
of a detectable protein; this would involve including transactivators,
transcription factors, or repressors in the construct containing the helix
and the NLS. Of course, the nuclear localization signal--derived constructs
can also be detected in the nucleus directly, using a direct detectable
label of the sort described above--e.g., GFP, a partner in an
antibody/antigen interaction, or an enzymatic activity, or a radiolabel.
For example, in one preferred format, the amphipathic helix or a larger
protein comprising said helix is coupled to a nuclear localization signal
and to a transactivator. The host cell is modified to contain an expression
system for a detectable protein, for example, green fluorescent protein in
its genome. The transactivator then can effect the expression of the green
fluorescent protein under conditions wherein the protocol or compound to be
tested disrupts the binding of the amphipathic helix with the cytoplasmic
membrane, thus permitting the nuclear localization signal to transport the
construct to the nucleus where the transactivator can effect expression of
the GFP. Alternative proteins whose expression can be detected are those,
such as GFP, that are detectable per se or may be detectable by virtue of
their effects on cellular growth, such as his3, leu2, .beta.-galactosidase,
.beta.-glucoronidase, SV40T antigen, chloramphenicol acetyl transferase
(CAT), hygromycin B phosphotransferase, SEAP or cell surface antigens such
as CD4. In addition to transactivators, transcription factors which enhance
expression include derivatives of lexa, cI, or gal4 DNA binding domains
fused to activation domains of B42, VP16 and the like.
Again, the essential feature is the detection of the effect of the proposed
protocol, compounds or mixtures of compounds on the interaction of the
amphipathic helix, whether supplied per se or in the context of a larger
protein, with the cytoplasmic membranes. The foregoing suggested assay
formats are merely exemplary and a wide variety of such formats will be
apparent to one of skill in the art. Any such assay method is appropriate;
the design of such assays and forms of label draws on a wide literature
available to the practitioner.
By conducting the foregoing assays, compounds and/or protocols are
identified which will be effective in treating HCV infection. By "treating"
is meant both therapeutic and prophylactic treatment, and refers to a
desirable effect on viral load, or symptomology, or any desirable outcome
which mitigates the negative consequences of the typical progress of HCV
infection. The term "treat" is not to be construed to imply absolute cure or
absolute prevention. Any helpful amelioration or repression of the infection
is sufficient to meet this definition.
Compounds thus identified can be administered in conventional ways using
standard pharmaceutical formulations such as those set forth in Remington's
Pharmaceutical Sciences, latest edition, Mack Publishing Co., Easton, Pa.,
incorporated herein by reference. (See also, References 23-33.) Various
enteral or parenteral routes of administration may be used, including
administering by injection, such as intravenous, intramuscular, subcutaneous
and the like, or by oral administration or by suppository. In addition,
sustained release compositions can also be used.
The terms "an effective amount," "an anti-HCV effective amount," or a
"pharmaceutically effective amount" of a peptide of the present invention as
applied to such molecules refers to an amount of a peptide, or combination
of two or more peptides as disclosed herein, effective in reducing or
ameliorating conditions, symptoms, or disorders associated with HCV
infection or associated pathogenesis in patients, and/or in reducing viral
levels in vitro or in vivo.
Effective amounts of peptides for the treatment or prevention of HCV
infections, delivery vehicles containing peptides or constructs encoding the
same, agonists, and treatment protocols, can be determined by conventional
means. For example, the medical practitioner can commence treatment with a
low dose of one or more peptides in a subject or patient in need thereof,
and then increase the dosage, or systematically vary the dosage regimen,
monitor the effects thereof on the patient or subject, and adjust the dosage
or treatment regimen to maximize the desired therapeutic effect. Further
discussion of optimization of dosage and treatment regimens can be found in
Benet et al., in Goodman & Gilman's The Pharmacological Basis of
Therapeutics, Ninth Edition, Hardman et al., Eds., McGraw-Hill, New York,
(1996), Chapter 1, pp. 3-27, and L. A. Bauer, in Pharmacotherapy, A
Pathophysiologic Approach, Fourth Edition, DiPiro et al., Eds., Appleton &
Lange, Stamford, Conn., (1999), Chapter 3, pp. 21-43, and the references
cited therein, to which the reader is referred.
The dosage levels and mode of administration will be dependent on the nature
of the compound identified and the particular situation of the subject.
Optimization of routes of administration, dosage levels, and adjustment of
protocols, including monitoring systems to assess effectiveness of the
treatment are routine matters well within ordinary skill. Protocols which
are identified using the intracellular assays set forth above must, of
course, be modified in the context of treatment of subjects, and this, too,
falls within the skill of the practitioner.
Typically, the compounds that are identified by the methods of the invention
will be "small molecules"--i.e., synthetic organic structures typical of
pharmaceuticals. Examples of such "small molecules" are found, for example,
in the Physicians' Desk Reference (with respect to approved drugs), the
Merck Index, and the U.S. Pharmacopoeia. However, such compounds may also
include peptides, peptidomimetics, nucleic acids, peptide nucleic acids,
carbohydrates, lipids, and the like. As noted above, the HCV nonstructural
protein amphipathic helix used in these assays may be the native helix, both
alone and in the context of a larger protein and the assays may also utilize
a homologous form of the helix included within the definition above which
retains the spatial and charge configuration of the native form.
In addition to compounds identified by means of the foregoing assays,
protocols and substances useful in treating HCV infection can be formulated
and utilized a priori. For example, the helix itself, or a functional
fragment thereof can readily be used in treatment by virtue of its ability
to bind the helix as it resides in an HCV non-structural protein itself or
to compete with the helix as it resides in an HCV non-structural protein
itself for sites on the cytoplasmic membrane to which the helix will bind.
Thus, formulations of the HCV nonstructural protein amphipathic helix or
functional fragment thereof can be used directly to treat HCV infection.
Typically, these formulations will contain peptides bearing the helix of
less than 60 amino acids, in another embodiment less than 50 amino acids, in
another embodiment less than 30 amino acids, and, in yet another embodiment
less than 25 amino acids in another embodiment, not be less than 4 amino
acids, and may, in addition to the peptide region bearing the helix, further
contain components to enhance membrane penetration. The peptides comprising
the helix may be as short as 10-15 amino acids, 6-9 amino acids or 4-6 amino
acids, so long as functionality in terms of competitive binding, or
inhibition of binding, is retained. Methods to synthesize such peptides are,
of course, well known, both direct and recombinant methods may be used.
Thus, a peptide useful in the method of the invention as to its helix-based
antiviral activity will typically contain from about 4 to 60 amino acids,
and certainly far less than the several hundred amino acids contained in the
native viral protein from which it can be derived. This relatively short
peptide may optionally be coupled to additional sequence either for
labeling, or, more typically, for conferring the ability to enter cells.
Such membrane penetration facilitators are known, for example, the HIV-tat
peptide or MTSs described herein, are able to introduce non-native proteins
into cells. The peptides to be administered will thus contain a portion
comprising the amphipathic helix and a heterologous portion for facilitating
cellular entry. Entry can also be facilitated by liposomes or cationic
polymers, for example. However, wild type NS5A is able to cross the membrane
without the assistance of a facilitator. Wild type NS5A is capable of
entering the cell without any previously described MTS peptide or other
facilitator.
As used herein "functional" refers to a protein, peptide, helix or antibody,
or fragment thereof, which possesses the ability to inhibit the binding of a
nonstructural HCV protein, for example, NS4B or NS5A, to a cell membrane.
The peptides useful in the methods of the invention can also be generated in
the subject to be treated by virtue of administering expression systems for
those peptides consisting entirely of gene-encoded amino acids. These
expression systems may be introduced as naked DNA, as expression vectors
suitable for transfection of mammalian cells, or preferably using adenoviral
or retroviral or other suitable viral vectors.
As described above, however, these competitor peptides need not be the
native sequences per se and need not even be peptides per se, but may
contain isosteric linkages or other polymeric features that result in
similar charge/shape features as compared to the native helices.
Peptides, or compounds with similar charge/shape features and having the
activity of the peptides described herein, can be identified by phage
display using wild-type amphipathic helix and a mutant amphipathic helix
peptides as positive and negative selectors, respectively.
The compositions or agents of the invention may comprise, consist
essentially of, or consist of the peptide sequences disclosed herein. The
phrase "consists essentially of or consisting essentially of" or the like,
when applied to anti-HCV peptides encompassed by the present invention
refers to peptide sequences like those disclosed herein, but which contain
additional amino acids (or analogs or derivatives thereof as discussed
above). Such additional amino acids, etc., however, do not materially affect
the basic and novel characteristic(s) of these peptides in modulating,
attenuating, or inhibiting HCV infection, replication, and/or pathogenesis,
including the specific quantitative effects of these peptides, compared to
those of the corresponding peptides disclosed herein.
In one approach, the agent may be a transdominant inhibitor of the membrane
association function whereby forms of the amphipathic helix that interfere
with the ability of the helix to form oligomers can be used. Thus, by
generating or providing a mutant form of the helix containing one or more
amino acid substitutions, this form may associate with the native helix to
provide an inactive form or rendering it unable to dimerize or oligomerize
with additional native forms. In one approach, the decoy peptide is mutated
to convert hydrophobic amino acids to hydrophilic ones thus destroying the
hydrophobic face of the helix. For example, mutated versions of the peptide
sequence for NS5A strains would include
In another approach, the agent is a competitive inhibitor of the amphipathic
helix. These competitive inhibitors may interrupt the binding between the
helix and the membrane, achieving the desired effect. Such inhibitors may be
fragments of the wild type sequence of the amphipathic sequence or variants
or mutants thereof. Fragments of the HCV nonstructural proteins that may be
used as competitive inhibitors may include, but are not limited to:
Another competitive inhibitor of NS5A would include:
SGSWLRDVWDWICTVLTDFKTWLQSKL (SEQ ID NO:14) and variants and mutants thereof.
Variants and mutants of this peptide would include a peptide with one or
more of the following amino acid substitutions: substitute of L at amino
acid 16 by A or K; or substitution of the T at amino acid 17 by A; or
substitution of the D at amino acid 18 by A; or substitution of the F at
amino acid 19 by A; or substitution of the K at amino acid 20 by A; or
substitution of the W at amino acid 22 by A; or substitution of the L at
amino acid 23 by K, and derivatives thereof. Another such mutant of HS5A is -- see Original Patent.
A mutant and competitive
inhibitor, of NS4B may include the sequence -- see Original Patent.
While the majority of the
above mutations and substitutions are conservative (i.e. wild type
hydrophobic residues are substituted with additional hydrophobic residues
(for example, A to F), charged residues are substituted with similarly
charged residues, etc.), it is noted that nonconservative substitutions may
also be performed. For example, where a wild type hydrophobic residue is
substituted with a hydrophilic residue, or a negatively charged residue (for
example, D) is substituted with a positively charged residue (for example,
K).
Where the agent is a competitive inhibitor, some of the above mutations
would enhance the inhibitory activity of the peptide, others would
completely or partially abolish the inhibitory activity of the peptide.
Mutations may be observed alone or in combination, for example, any one
substitution, X.sub.1-28, occurs within the context of the wild type
sequence at any one time, a combination of two mutations such as: X.sub.2
and X.sub.5, X.sub.2 and X.sub.19, or X.sub.5 and X.sub.19 or three
mutations are found in the same peptide, X.sub.2, with X.sub.5, and
X.sub.19.
In another embodiment, the agent may be a complementary peptide to the
helix. Complementary peptides may interrupt the binding between the helix
and the membrane, achieving the desired effect. Such complementary peptides
may also inhibit the formation of the amphipathic helix, may interact or
bind to the helix to inhibit binding of the helix to cellular membranes, or
may otherwise inhibit the amphipathic helices.
For example, the HCV genomic RNA sequence that codes for the NS4B
amphipathic helix in the HCV genotype 1A sequence is -- see Original Patent.
(Kolykhalov, A. A. and Rice,
C. M., Science 277 (5325), 570-574 (1997); GenBank Accession No.: AF009606.)
The protein translation of the above sequence is:
YIEQGMMLAEQFKQKALGLLQTASRQAE (SEQ ID NO: 18). The reverse complement cDNA
sequence corresponding to the HCV genomic RNA sequence that codes for the
NS4B amphipathic helix (GenBank Accession No.: AF009606) is -- see Original Patent.
The complementary peptide
translated from the reverse complement sequence is:
LCLAGRGLQEAEGLLLELLSEHHPLLDV (SEQ ID NO: 20).
This complementary peptide, as
a whole, or in part, may be active as an HCV antiviral or may be useful in
the prediction of small molecules that are HCV antivirals. In one embodiment
a fragment of this complementary peptide comprising 6-27 amino acids may be
used in the discovery of HCV antivirals. Table 1 (see Original Patent) sets
forth exemplary peptides (SEQ ID NOS: 21-295) of this embodiment.
In a particular embodiment, the complementary peptides of the invention are
used, in whole or in part, in the prediction of small molecules that are HCV
antivirals. "Small molecule" as defined above, may include synthetic organic
structures typical of pharmaceuticals, and may also include peptides,
nucleic acids, peptide nucleic acids, carbohydrates, lipids, and the like.
Additionally, small molecules, as used herein, may include chemically
synthesized peptidomimetics of the 6-mer to 9-mer peptides of the invention.
Additionally, the HCV genomic RNA sequence that codes for the NS5A
amphipathic helix in the HCV genotype 1A sequence is -- see Original Patent.
The peptides that mimic the
helices and functional fragments thereof are administered in formulations
and by routes well understood. A variety of methods for introducing such
substances are known, typically, by injection, aerosol administration,
suppository, and, with proper design, oral administration. This general
statement is true as well with respect to providing expression systems for
peptides represented by the helix mimics.
In addition to the peptides or other compounds of the invention, combination
therapies including known HCV inhibitors can be utilized in the present
invention. For example, it may be desirable to administer both a peptide or
peptides of the invention in combination with interferon to a subject
infected with HCV. Other drugs or compounds known in the art to be effective
against HCV, can also be used.
In one embodiment, the invention provides a method of screening compounds,
to identify those that selectively inhibit the binding of HCV nonstructural
proteins (for example, NS4B or NS5A) and cellular membranes. Methods known
to those of skill in the art, can be readily adapted to detect interference
with the binding of these components. The method of screening may involve
high-throughput techniques. For example, to screen for compounds that
selectively inhibit the binding of HCV nonstructural proteins and cellular
membranes, a synthetic reaction mix, a viral fragment or component, or a
preparation of any thereof, comprising an HCV nonstructural protein and a
labeled substrate or ligand of such polypeptide is incubated in the absence
or the presence of a candidate molecule that may inhibit the binding of the
HCV nonstructural proteins and the cellular membrane. The ability of the
candidate molecule to inhibit the binding of the HCV nonstructural protein
and the cellular membrane is reflected in decreased binding of the labeled
ligand or decreased production of product from such substrate.
In another aspect, the screening can be performed by adding the candidate
compound to intact cells that have been infected by HCV, or that contain an
HCV replicon, and then examining the component of interest to demonstrate
the effect on this component, or the effect on viral or replicon
replication. An exemplary cell-based in vitro assay for this purpose is
disclosed in PCT International Publication WO 02/18369. Alternatively, the
screening can be performed by adding the test agent to in vitro translation
reactions and then proceeding with the established analysis. As another
alternative, purified or partially purified components which have been
determined to interact with one another by the methods described above can
be placed under conditions in which the interaction between them would
normally occur, with and without the addition of the candidate compound, and
the procedures previously established to analyze the interaction can be used
to assess the impact of the candidate compound. However their anti-HCV
activity is initially assayed, peptide or other inhibitors of the present
invention should cause inhibition of infection, replication, or pathogenesis
of Hepatitis C Virus in vitro or in vivo when introduced into a host cell
containing the virus, and exhibit an IC.sub.50 in the range of from about
0.0001 nM to 100 .mu.M in an in vitro assay for at least one step in
infection, replication, or pathogenesis of HCV, more preferably from about
0.0001 nM to 75 .mu.M, more preferably from about 0.0001 nM to 50 .mu.M,
more preferably from about 0.0001 mM to 25 .mu.M, more preferably from about
0.0001 nM to 10 .mu.M, and even more preferably from about 0.0001 nM to 1 .mu.M.
In another embodiment of the invention, the method of screening may be by
phage display. A method of obtaining selective ligands that bind a chosen
target is to select from a library of proteins or peptides displayed on
phage. In order to obtain a novel binding protein against a chosen target,
such as an amphipathic helix region of an HCV component, DNA molecules, each
encoding a protein or peptide fragment thereof, and a structural signal
calling for the display of the protein on the outer surface of a chosen
genetic package (bacterial cell, bacterial spore or phage) are introduced
into a genetic package. The protein is expressed and the potential binding
domain is displayed on the outer surface of the package. The package is then
exposed to the target. If the genetic package binds to the target, then it
is confirmed that the corresponding binding domain is indeed displayed by
the genetic package. Packages which display the binding domain (and thereby
bind the target) are separated from those which do not. For example, in the
present invention, the target may be the amphipathic helix or a mutated
amphipathic helix. Potential peptides, which may then be used as anti-HCV
agents, are screened by determination of which will bind to the amphipathic
helix or a mutated amphipathic helix. Preferred peptides are those that not
only bind to the amphipathic helix, but in addition, block or inhibit the
amphipathic helix from binding to its receptor or binding site, thereby
inhibiting infectivity. Examples of peptides identified by phage display are
set forth in Table 3 (see Original Patent).
In all of the embodiments of the invention, the active agent which will
interact, generally, either with the sites on the cytoplasmic membrane to
which the amphipathic helix binds or will interact with the amphipathic
helix itself, may be derivatized or coupled to additional components. By
"derivatives" of these agents is meant modifications thereof that do not
interfere with their ability to interact with the sites or the helix, but
may optionally confer some additional useful property. One particularly
useful property is the ability to penetrate cell membranes, and preferred
among the derivatives or conjugated forms are those coupled to such
facilitators. An additional desired coupled component may be a labeling
component such as a fluorescent dye, an enzyme, or a radioisotope. One
particularly useful label is, for example, green fluorescent protein in any
of its many colors and forms. Green fluorescent protein thus, includes, not
only forms of this fluorescent protein that fluoresce green, but also those
that fluoresce various other colors such as red and blue. These forms of the
protein are commercially available as are recombinant materials for their
production.
The compositions of the invention can be administered as conventional HCV
therapeutics. The compositions of the invention may include more than one
ingredient which interrupts the binding of the amphipathic helix to the
membranes and more than one peptide of the invention.
The precise formulations and modes of administration of the anti-HCV
compositions of the invention will depend on the nature of the anti-HCV
agent, the condition of the subject, and the judgment of the practitioner.
Design of such administration and formulation is routine optimization
generally carried out without difficulty by the practitioner.
In addition to the assay methods, methods to identify compounds or protocols
against HCV infection, and methods to treat HCV infections as set forth
above, the invention provides compositions which are effective to elicit
immunological responses to HCV in appropriate subjects, such as humans or
other animals subject to HCV infection.
Administration may be performed using conventional methods, typically by
injection. The elicited immunological response is helpful in general HCV
prophylaxis.
Claim 1 of 17 Claims
1. A method for assessing activity of a
candidate compound in interfering with binding of a Hepatitis C virus (HCV)
nonstructural protein with a eukaryotic cell cytoplasmic membrane,
comprising: assessing, in the presence and absence of a candidate
compound, binding of a polypeptide comprising an amphipathic helix of an
N-terminal region of an HCV nonstructural protein with cytoplasmic
membranes of a eukaryotic cell, wherein the non-structural protein is NS4B
or NS5A; wherein reduced binding in the presence of the candidate compound
relative to a level of binding in the absence of the candidate compound
indicates activity of the candidate compound in interfering with binding
of HCV nonstructural protein to the cytoplasmic membranes. ____________________________________________
If you want to learn more
about this patent, please go directly to the U.S.
Patent and Trademark Office Web site to access the full
patent.
|