|
|
Title:
Druggable regions in the dengue virus envelope glycoprotein and methods of
using the same
United States Patent: 7,524,624
Issued: April 28, 2009
Inventors: Modis; Yorgo
(Brookline, MA), Harrison; Stephen C. (Cambridge, MA)
Assignee: Children's
Medical Center Corporation (Boston, MA)
Appl. No.: 11/257,777
Filed: October 24, 2005
|
|
|
Outsourcing Guide
|
Abstract
The present invention relates to novel
druggable regions discovered in dengue virus envelope glycoprotein, or
dengue virus E protein, which is a class II viral E protein. The present
invention further relates to methods of using the druggable regions to
screen potential candidate therapeutics for diseases caused by viruses
having class II E proteins, e.g. viral fusion inhibitors.
Description of the
Invention
A. General
We have determined the structures of the E protein in both its pre-fusion
and post-fusion conformations.
The pre-fusion structure was determinned by solving the structure of a
soluble fragment (residues 1-394) of the E protein from dengue virus type 2.
This fragment contains all but about 45 residues of the E-protein ectodomain
(FIG. 1A, see Original Patent). It resembles closely, in its dimeric
structure and in the details of its protein fold, the E protein from
tick-borne encephalitis (TBE) virus, studied previously. We have examined
crystals grown in both the presence and the absence of the detergent n-octyl-.beta.-D-glucoside,
.beta.-OG. The key difference between the two structures is a local
rearrangement of the "k1" .beta.-hairpin (residues 268-280) and the
concomitant opening up of a hydrophobic pocket, occupied by a molecule of
.beta.-OG. Mutations affecting the pH threshold for fusion map to the
hydrophobic pocket, which we propose is a hinge point in the
fusion-activating conformational change. Detergent binding marks the k1
.beta.-hairpin and associated pocket as a potential target for viral fusion
inhibitors. We have also discovered another region, the domain 1-3 region,
which may serve as a target for viral fusion inhibitors.
The post-fusion structure of the soluble E ectodomain (sE) in its trimeric,
post-fusion state reveals striking differences from the dimeric, pre-fusion
form. The elongated trimer bears three "fusion loops" at one end, to insert
into the host-cell membrane. Their structure allows us to model directly how
they interact with a lipid bilayer. The protein folds back on itself,
directing its C-terminus towards the fusion loop. We propose a fusion
mechanism driven by essentially irreversible conformational changes in
dengue virus E protein and facilitated by fusion-loop insertion into the
outer bilayer leaflet. Specific features of the folded-back structure
suggest strategies for inhibiting flavivirus entry, as well as druggable
regions. The regions may serve as a target for viral fusion inhibitors and
assays to discover such inhibitors.
Hence, we have discovered a variety of novel, structurally defined druggable
regions which may present targets for a specific viral fusion inhibitor for
dengue virus and other viruses having class II E protein. Because dengue
virus type 2 E protein is strongly homologous to other dengue viral types,
as well as other flavivirus E proteins and class II E proteins (Lindenbach
and Rice, 2001, Rey, et al. 1995, Hahn, et al. 1998), these binding sites
are likely present in those E proteins as well and may serve as targets for
specific viral fusion inhibitors for those viruses.
Finally, we have also discovered that peptides corresponding to residues
396-429 and 413-447 (in the "stem" region) of dengue envelope protein (E)
binds with fairly high affinity and specificity to the trimeric, post-fusion
form of sE, the fragment of E spanning residues 1-395, which we crystallized
first in the pre-fusion form and then in the post-fusion form. Inhibitor
peptides derived from stem sequences may block completion of the
conformational change by interacting with the relevant surfaces on the
clustered domains II. Such inhibitors would interfere with the second stage
of the conformational change. This peptide itself may serve as a specific
viral fusion inhibitor, or may provide the basis from which to design
improved specific viral fusion inhibitors.
C. Drug Discovery
C.1. Druggable Regions
Based in part on the structural information described in the
Exemplification, we have identified novel druggable regions in dengue virus
E protein. In one embodiment, the druggable region is comprised of the k1
hairpin or a portion thereof. In certain embodiments, the k1 hairpin may be
comprised of at least one of residues 268-280 of a dengue virus E protein or
the homologous residues in other class II E protein. In other embodiments,
the druggable region or active site region may be comprised of the k1
hairpin and at least one of residues 47-54, 128-137, and 187-207.
In yet another embodiment, the druggable region may comprise the regions
involved in the binding of residues 396-429 (the "stem" region of dengue
envelope protein E) binds to the trimeric, post-fusion form of dengue virus
E protein or other flavivirus E protein. In one embodiment, the druggable
region is comprised of the stem region or a portion thereof. The stem region
comprises residues 396-447, or fragments thereof, for example 396-429 and
413-447. In another embodiment, the druggable region is comprised of the
channel in which the stem region binds. The channel is comprised of the
residues at the trimer interface formed by domain II of each subunit in the
trimer. Domain II consists of residues 52-132 and 193-280. A second region
is the channel where the stem binds, formed by residues in domain II.
In another embodiment, the druggable region is comprised of the domain I-II
region. In certain embodiments, the domain I-III region may be comprised of
at least one of residues 38-40; 143-147; 294-296; and 354-365 of a dengue
virus E protein or the homologous residues in other class II E protein. In
other embodiments, the druggable region may be comprised of the domain
I-domain III linker (residues 294-301).
In yet another embodiment, a druggable region is comprised of the fusion
loop or a portion thereof.
Other regions of protein may in certain embodiments comprise a druggable
region. For example, the hydrophobic core beneath the k1 hairpin or a
portion thereof may comprise a druggable region. In another example, a
druggable region may comprise domain II or a portion thereof. In still
another example, a druggable region may comprise domain III or a portion
thereof. In other examples, the pH-dependent hinge may serve as a druggable
region. Further, a region or portion of a region of the E protein involved
in trimerization, such as for example, the regions of domain II involved in
trimerization, may present a druggable region. A region or a portion of a
region involved in the stem fold back conformational change may comprise a
druggable region, for example, such regions as the stem-domain II contact
regions, the trimeric N terminal inner core, and C terminal outer layer
surfaces on the clustered domains II, as well as the 53-residue stem. In
certain embodiments, a druggable region may consist of the entire fragment
of the E protein spanning residues 1-395.
In yet another aspect, the present invention is directed toward methods of
identifying and designing modulators which bind with, interact with, or
modulate the function or activity of an active or binding site of a dengue
virus E protein or other class II E protein.
C.2. Modulators, Modulator Design and Screening Using the Subject Druggable
Regions
In one aspect, the present invention provides methods of screening the
subject druggable regions for potential modulators, as well as methods of
designing such modulators. Modulators to polypeptides of the invention and
other structurally related molecules, and complexes containing the same, may
be identified and developed as set forth below and otherwise using
techniques and methods known to those of skill in the art. The modulators of
the invention may be employed, for instance, to inhibit and treat disease
caused by a flavivirus or other virus having class II E protein, such as
dengue fever, dengue hemorrhagic fever, tick-borne encephalitis, West Nile
virus disease, yellow fever, Kyasanur Forest disease, louping ill, hepatitis
C, Ross River virus disease, and O'nyong fever.
In one aspect, the present invention is directed towards a modulator that
interacts with the subject druggable regions so as to reduce the activity of
the dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein. Such modulators may
in certain embodiments interact with a druggable region of the invention. In
still another aspect, the present invention is directed toward a modulator
that is a fragment of (or homolog of such fragment or mimetic of such
fragment) the druggable region of a dengue virus E protein or other viral
class II E protein and competes with that druggable region. Modulators of
any of the above-described druggable regions may be used alone or in
complementary approaches to treat dengue viral or other viral infections.
In certain embodiments, a modulator interacts with the k1 hairpin so as to
preclude it from moving, thereby modulating the activity of the dengue virus
E protein or other flavivirus E protein. In another aspect, the present
invention is directed towards a modulator that interacts with the stem
region or the channel so as to preclude them from interacting, thereby
modulating the activity of the dengue virus E protein or other flavivirus E
protein. Such modulators may be, as described above, derived from either the
stem region or the channel, and compete with the stem region or channel for
binding. In still other embodiments, a modulator of class II E protein
activity interacts with the domain I-III region. The modulator may also
preclude the movement of the domain I-III region. In another aspect, the
present invention is directed towards a modulator that interacts with the
fusion loop so as to preclude it from moving, thereby modulating the
activity of the dengue virus E protein or other E protein.
Further, the present invention is in part directed toward an inhibitor that
comprises SEQ ID NO: 3 or SEQ ID NO: 4, as well as fragments, homologs,
variants, orthologs, and peptidomimetics thereof. Further, the present
invention is directed towards an inhibitor that interacts with the relevant
surfaces on the clustered domains II, so that completion of the
conformational change is inhibited and thereby inhibiting the activity of
the dengue virus E protein or other E protein. The present invention is also
directed towards an inhibitor that interacts with the pocket beneath the k1
hairpin to infere with the first stage of the conformational change, thereby
modulating the activity of the dengue virus E protein or other E protein.
Such inhibitors may be used in complementary approaches to treat dengue
viral or other viral infections.
A variety of methods for inhibiting the growth or infectivity of
flaviviruses using the modulators are contemplated by the present invention.
For example, exemplary methods involve contacting a flavivirus with a
modulator thought or shown to be effective against such pathogen.
For example, in one aspect, the present invention contemplates a method for
treating a patient suffering from an infection of dengue fever or other
flavivirus comprising administering to the patient an amount of a modulator
effective to modulate the expression and/or activity of a dengue virus E
protein or other class II E protein. In certain instances, the animal is a
human or a livestock animal such as a cow, pig, goat or sheep. The present
invention further contemplates a method for treating a subject suffering
from a flavivirus-related, alphavirus-related, or hepatitis-related disease
or disorder, comprising administering to an animal having the condition a
therapeutically effective amount of a molecule identified using one of the
methods of the present invention.
In another embodiment, modulators of a dengue virus E protein or other class
II E protein, or biological complexes containing them, may be used in the
manufacture of a medicament for any number of uses, including, for example,
treating any disease or other treatable condition of a patient (including
humans and animals), and particularly a disease caused by a flavivirus or
other virus having class II E protein, such as, for example, one of the
following: dengue fever, dengue hemorrhagic fever, tick-borne encephalitis,
West Nile virus disease, yellow fever, Kyasanur Forest disease, louping ill,
hepatitis C, Ross River virus disease, and O'nyong fever. (a) Modulator
Design
A number of techniques can be used to screen, identify, select and design
chemical entities capable of associating with a dengue virus E protein or
other class II E protein, structurally homologous molecules, and other
molecules. Knowledge of the structure for a dengue virus E protein or other
class II E protein, determined in accordance with the methods described
herein, permits the design and/or identification of molecules and/or other
modulators which have a shape complementary to the conformation of a dengue
virus E protein or other class II E protein, or more particularly, a
druggable region thereof. It is understood that such techniques and methods
may use, in addition to the exact structural coordinates and other
information for a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein,
structural equivalents thereof described above (including, for example,
those structural coordinates that are derived from the structural
coordinates of amino acids contained in a druggable region as described
above).
The term "chemical entity," as used herein, refers to chemical compounds,
complexes of two or more chemical compounds, and fragments of such compounds
or complexes. In certain instances, it is desirable to use chemical entities
exhibiting a wide range of structural and functional diversity, such as
compounds exhibiting different shapes (e.g., flat aromatic rings(s),
puckered aliphatic rings(s), straight and branched chain aliphatics with
single, double, or triple bonds) and diverse functional groups (e.g.,
carboxylic acids, esters, ethers, amines, aldehydes, ketones, and various
heterocyclic rings).
In one aspect, the method of drug design generally includes computationally
evaluating the potential of a selected chemical entity to associate with any
of the molecules or complexes of the present invention (or portions
thereof). For example, this method may include the steps of (a) employing
computational means to perform a fitting operation between the selected
chemical entity and a druggable region of the molecule or complex; and (b)
analyzing the results of said fitting operation to quantify the association
between the chemical entity and the druggable region.
A chemical entity may be examined either through visual inspection or
through the use of computer modeling using a docking program such as GRAM,
DOCK, or AUTODOCK (Dunbrack et al., Folding & Design, 2:27-42 (1997)). This
procedure can include computer fitting of chemical entities to a target to
ascertain how well the shape and the chemical structure of each chemical
entity will complement or interfere with the structure of a dengue virus E
protein or other class II E protein (Bugg et al., Scientific American, Dec.:
92-98 (1993); West et al., TIPS, 16:67-74 (1995)). Computer programs may
also be employed to estimate the attraction, repulsion, and steric hindrance
of the chemical entity to a druggable region, for example. Generally, the
tighter the fit (e.g., the lower the steric hindrance, and/or the greater
the attractive force) the more potent the chemical entity will be because
these properties are consistent with a tighter binding constant.
Furthermore, the more specificity in the design of a chemical entity the
more likely that the chemical entity will not interfere with related
proteins, which may minimize potential side-effects due to unwanted
interactions.
A variety of computational methods for molecular design, in which the steric
and electronic properties of druggable regions are used to guide the design
of chemical entities, are known: Cohen et al. (1990) J. Med. Cam. 33:
883-894; Kuntz et al. (1982) J. Mol. Biol. 161: 269-288; DesJarlais (1988)
J. Med. Cam. 31: 722-729; Bartlett et al. (1989) Spec. Publ., Roy. Soc.
Chem. 78: 182-196; Goodford et al. (1985) J. Med. Cam. 28: 849-857; and
Desjarlais et al. J. Med. Cam. 29: 2149-2153. Directed methods generally
fall into two categories: (1) design by analogy in which 3-D structures of
known chemical entities (such as from a crystallographic database) are
docked to the druggable region and scored for goodness-of-fit; and (2) de
novo design, in which the chemical entity is constructed piece-wise in the
druggable region. The chemical entity may be screened as part of a library
or a database of molecules. Databases which may be used include ACD
(Molecular Designs Limited), NCI (National Cancer Institute), CCDC
(Cambridge Crystallographic Data Center), CAST (Chemical Abstract Service),
Derwent (Derwent Information Limited), Maybridge (Maybridge Chemical Company
Ltd), Aldrich (Aldrich Chemical Company), DOCK (University of California in
San Francisco), and the Directory of Natural Products (Chapman & Hall).
Computer programs such as CONCORD (Tripos Associates) or DB-Converter
(Molecular Simulations Limited) can be used to convert a data set
represented in two dimensions to one represented in three dimensions.
Chemical entities may be tested for their capacity to fit spatially with a
druggable region or other portion of a target protein. As used herein, the
term "fits spatially" means that the three-dimensional structure of the
chemical entity is accommodated geometrically by a druggable region. A
favorable geometric fit occurs when the surface area of the chemical entity
is in close proximity with the surface area of the druggable region without
forming unfavorable interactions. A favorable complementary interaction
occurs where the chemical entity interacts by hydrophobic, aromatic, ionic,
dipolar, or hydrogen donating and accepting forces. Unfavorable interactions
may be steric hindrance between atoms in the chemical entity and atoms in
the druggable region.
If a model of the present invention is a computer model, the chemical
entities may be positioned in a druggable region through computational
docking. If, on the other hand, the model of the present invention is a
structural model, the chemical entities may be positioned in the druggable
region by, for example, manual docking. As used herein the term "docking"
refers to a process of placing a chemical entity in close proximity with a
druggable region, or a process of finding low energy conformations of a
chemical entity/druggable region complex.
In an illustrative embodiment, the design of potential modulator begins from
the general perspective of shape complimentary for the druggable region of a
dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein, and a search algorithm
is employed which is capable of scanning a database of small molecules of
known three-dimensional structure for chemical entities which fit
geometrically with the target druggable region. Most algorithms of this type
provide a method for finding a wide assortment of chemical entities that are
complementary to the shape of a druggable region of a dengue virus E protein
or other class II E protein. Each of a set of chemical entities from a
particular data-base, such as the Cambridge Crystallographic Data Bank (CCDB)
(Allen et al. (1973) J. Chem. Doc. 13: 119), is individually docked to the
druggable region of a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein in
a number of geometrically permissible orientations with use of a docking
algorithm. In certain embodiments, a set of computer algorithms called DOCK,
can be used to characterize the shape of invaginations and grooves that form
the active sites and recognition surfaces of the druggable region (Kuntz et
al. (1982) J. Mol. Biol. 161: 269-288). The program can also search a
database of small molecules for templates whose shapes are complementary to
particular binding sites of a dengue virus E protein or other class II E
protein (DesJarlais et al. (1988) J Med Chem 31: 722-729).
The orientations are evaluated for goodness-of-fit and the best are kept for
further examination using molecular mechanics programs, such as AMBER or
CHARMM. Such algorithms have previously proven successful in finding a
variety of chemical entities that are complementary in shape to a druggable
region.
Goodford (1985, J Med Chem 28:849-857) and Boobbyer et al. (1989, J Med Chem
32:1083-1094) have produced a computer program (GRID) which seeks to
determine regions of high affinity for different chemical groups (termed
probes) of the druggable region. GRID hence provides a tool for suggesting
modifications to known chemical entities that might enhance binding. It may
be anticipated that some of the sites discerned by GRID as regions of high
affinity correspond to "pharmacophoric patterns" determined inferentially
from a series of known ligands. As used herein, a "pharmacophoric pattern"
is a geometric arrangement of features of chemical entities that is believed
to be important for binding. Attempts have been made to use pharmacophoric
patterns as a search screen for novel ligands (Jakes et al. (1987) J Mol
Graph 5:41-48; Brint et al. (1987) J Graph 5:49-56; Jakes et al. (1986) J
Mol Graph 4:12-20).
Yet a further embodiment of the present invention utilizes a computer
algorithm such as CLIX which searches such databases as CCDB for chemical
entities which can be oriented with the druggable region in a way that is
both sterically acceptable and has a high likelihood of achieving favorable
chemical interactions between the chemical entity and the surrounding amino
acid residues. The method is based on characterizing the region in terms of
an ensemble of favorable binding positions for different chemical groups and
then searching for orientations of the chemical entities that cause maximum
spatial coincidence of individual candidate chemical groups with members of
the ensemble. The algorithmic details of CLIX is described in Lawrence et
al. (1992) Proteins 12:3141.
In this way, the efficiency with which a chemical entity may bind to or
interfere with a druggable region may be tested and optimized by
computational evaluation. For example, for a favorable association with a
druggable region, a chemical entity must preferably demonstrate a relatively
small difference in energy between its bound and fine states (i.e., a small
deformation energy of binding). Thus, certain, more desirable chemical
entities will be designed with a deformation energy of binding of not
greater than about 10 kcal/mole, and more preferably, not greater than 7
kcal/mole. Chemical entities may interact with a druggable region in more
than one conformation that is similar in overall binding energy. In those
cases, the deformation energy of binding is taken to be the difference
between the energy of the free entity and the average energy of the
conformations observed when the chemical entity binds to the target.
In this way, the present invention provides computer-assisted methods for
identifying or designing a potential modulator of the activity of a dengue
virus E protein or other class II E protein including: supplying a computer
modeling application with a set of structure coordinates of a molecule or
complex, the molecule or complex including at least a portion of a druggable
region from a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein; supplying
the computer modeling application with a set of structure coordinates of a
chemical entity; and determining whether the chemical entity is expected to
bind to the molecule or complex, wherein binding to the molecule or complex
is indicative of potential modulation of the activity of a dengue virus E
protein or other class II E protein.
In another aspect, the present invention provides a computer-assisted method
for identifying or designing a potential modulator to a dengue virus E
protein or other class II E protein, supplying a computer modeling
application with a set of structure coordinates of a molecule or complex,
the molecule or complex including at least a portion of a druggable region
of a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein; supplying the
computer modeling application with a set of structure coordinates for a
chemical entity; evaluating the potential binding interactions between the
chemical entity and active site of the molecule or molecular complex;
structurally modifying the chemical entity to yield a set of structure
coordinates for a modified chemical entity, and determining whether the
modified chemical entity is expected to bind to the molecule or complex,
wherein binding to the molecule or complex is indicative of potential
modulation of the dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein.
In one embodiment, a potential modulator can be obtained by screening a
peptide or other compound or chemical library (Scott and Smith, Science,
249:386-390 (1990); Cwirla et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 87:6378-6382
(1990); Devlin et al., Science, 249:404-406 (1990)). A potential modulator
selected in this manner could then be systematically modified by computer
modeling programs until one or more promising potential drugs are
identified. Such analysis has been shown to be effective in the development
of HIV protease modulators (Lam et al., Science 263:380-384 (1994); Wlodawer
et al., Ann. Rev. Biochem. 62:543-585 (1993); Appelt, Perspectives in Drug
Discovery and Design 1:23-48 (1993); Erickson, Perspectives in Drug
Discovery and Design 1:109-128 (1993)). Alternatively a potential modulator
may be selected from a library of chemicals such as those that can be
licensed from third parties, such as chemical and pharmaceutical companies.
A third alternative is to synthesize the potential modulator de novo.
For example, in certain embodiments, the present invention provides a method
for making a potential modulator for a dengue virus E protein or other class
II E protein, the method including synthesizing a chemical entity or a
molecule containing the chemical entity to yield a potential modulator of a
dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein, the chemical entity
having been identified during a computer-assisted process including
supplying a computer modeling application with a set of structure
coordinates of a molecule or complex, the molecule or complex including at
least one druggable region from a dengue virus E protein or other class II E
protein; supplying the computer modeling application with a set of structure
coordinates of a chemical entity; and determining whether the chemical
entity is expected to bind to the molecule or complex at the active site,
wherein binding to the molecule or complex is indicative of potential
modulation. This method may further include the steps of evaluating the
potential binding interactions between the chemical entity and the active
site of the molecule or molecular complex and structurally modifying the
chemical entity to yield a set of structure coordinates for a modified
chemical entity, which steps may be repeated one or more times.
Once a potential modulator is identified, it can then be tested in any
standard assay for the macromolecule depending of course on the
macromolecule, including in high throughput assays. Further refinements to
the structure of the modulator will generally be necessary and can be made
by the successive iterations of any and/or all of the steps provided by the
particular screening assay, in particular further structural analysis by
e.g., .sup.15N NMR relaxation rate determinations or x-ray crystallography
with the modulator bound to a dengue virus E protein or other class II E
protein. These studies may be performed in conjunction with biochemical
assays.
Once identified, a potential modulator may be used as a model structure, and
analogs to the compound can be obtained. The analogs are then screened for
their ability to bind to a dengue virus E protein or other class II E
protein. An analog of the potential modulator might be chosen as a modulator
when it binds to a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein with a
higher binding affinity than the predecessor modulator.
In a related approach, iterative drug design is used to identify modulators
of a target protein. Iterative drug design is a method for optimizing
associations between a protein and a modulator by determining and evaluating
the three dimensional structures of successive sets of protein/modulator
complexes. In iterative drug design, crystals of a series of
protein/modulator complexes are obtained and then the three-dimensional
structures of each complex is solved. Such an approach provides insight into
the association between the proteins and modulators of each complex. For
example, this approach may be accomplished by selecting modulators with
modulatory activity, obtaining crystals of this new protein/modulator
complex, solving the three dimensional structure of the complex, and
comparing the associations between the new protein/modulator complex and
previously solved protein/modulator complexes. By observing how changes in
the modulator affected the protein/modulator associations, these
associations may be optimized.
In addition to designing and/or identifying a chemical entity to associate
with a druggable region, as described above, the same techniques and methods
may be used to design and/or identify chemical entities that either
associate, or do not associate, with affinity regions, selectivity regions
or undesired regions of protein targets. By such methods, selectivity for
one or a few targets, or alternatively for multiple targets, from the same
species or from multiple species, can be achieved.
For example, a chemical entity may be designed and/or identified for which
the binding energy for one druggable region, e.g., an affinity region or
selectivity region, is more favorable than that for another region, e.g., an
undesired region, by about 20%, 30%, 50% to about 60% or more. It may be the
case that the difference is observed between (a) more than two regions, (b)
between different regions (selectivity, affinity or undesirable) from the
same target, (c) between regions of different targets, (d) between regions
of homologs from different species, or (e) between other combinations.
Alternatively, the comparison may be made by reference to the Kd, usually
the apparent Kd, of said chemical entity with the two or more regions in
question.
In another aspect, prospective modulators are screened for binding to two
nearby druggable regions on a target protein. For example, a modulator that
binds a first region of a target polypeptide does not bind a second nearby
region. Binding to the second region can be determined by monitoring changes
in a different set of amide chemical shifts in either the original screen or
a second screen conducted in the presence of a modulator (or potential
modulator) for the first region. From an analysis of the chemical shift
changes, the approximate location of a potential modulator for the second
region is identified. Optimization of the second modulator for binding to
the region is then carried out by screening structurally related compounds
(e.g., analogs as described above). When modulators for the first region and
the second region are identified, their location and orientation in the
ternary complex can be determined experimentally. On the basis of this
structural information, a linked compound, e.g., a consolidated modulator,
is synthesized in which the modulator for the first region and the modulator
for the second region are linked. In certain embodiments, the two modulators
are covalently linked to form a consolidated modulator. This consolidated
modulator may be tested to determine if it has a higher binding affinity for
the target than either of the two individual modulators. A consolidated
modulator is selected as a modulator when it has a higher binding affinity
for the target than either of the two modulators. Larger consolidated
modulators can be constructed in an analogous manner, e.g., linking three
modulators which bind to three nearby regions on the target to form a
multilinked consolidated modulator that has an even higher affinity for the
target than the linked modulator. In this example, it is assumed that is
desirable to have the modulator bind to all the druggable regions. However,
it may be the case that binding to certain of the druggable regions is not
desirable, so that the same techniques may be used to identify modulators
and consolidated modulators that show increased specificity based on binding
to at least one but not all druggable regions of a target.
The present invention provides a number of methods that use drug design as
described above. For example, in one aspect, the present invention
contemplates a method for designing a candidate compound for screening for
modulators of a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein, the
method comprising: (a) determining the three dimensional structure of a
crystallized dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein or a
fragment thereof; and (b) designing a candidate modulator based on the three
dimensional structure of the crystallized polypeptide or fragment.
In another aspect, the present invention contemplates a method for
identifying a potential modulator of a dengue virus E protein or other class
II E protein, the method comprising: (a) providing the three-dimensional
coordinates of a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein or a
fragment thereof; (b) identifying a druggable region of the polypeptide or
fragment; and (c) selecting from a database at least one compound that
comprises three dimensional coordinates which indicate that the compound may
bind the druggable region; (d) wherein the selected compound is a potential
modulator of a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein.
In another aspect, the present invention contemplates a method for
identifying a potential modulator of a molecule comprising a druggable
region similar to that of an E protein k1 hairpin, the method comprising:
(a) using the atomic coordinates of amino acid residues from a druggable
region, such as an E protein k1 hairpin, or a fragment thereof, .+-. a root
mean square deviation from the backbone atoms of the amino acids of not more
than 1.5 .ANG., to generate a three-dimensional structure of a molecule
comprising an E protein k1 hairpin-like druggable region; (b) employing the
three dimensional structure to design or select the potential modulator; (c)
synthesizing the modulator; and (d) contacting the modulator with the
molecule to determine the ability of the modulator to interact with the
molecule.
In another aspect, the present invention contemplates an apparatus for
determining whether a compound is a potential modulator of a dengue virus E
protein or other class II E protein, the apparatus comprising: (a) a memory
that comprises: (i) the three dimensional coordinates and identities of the
atoms of a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein or a fragment
thereof that form a druggable site, such as for example, an E protein k1
hairpin; and (ii) executable instructions; and (b) a processor that is
capable of executing instructions to: (i) receive three-dimensional
structural information for a candidate compound; (ii) determine if the
three-dimensional structure of the candidate compound is complementary to
the structure of the interior of the druggable site; and (iii) output the
results of the determination.
In another aspect, the present invention contemplates a method for designing
a potential compound for the prevention or treatment of a flavivirus related
disease or disorder, the method comprising: (a) providing the three
dimensional structure of a crystallized dengue virus E protein or other
class II E protein, or a fragment thereof; (b) synthesizing a potential
compound for the prevention or treatment of flavivirus related disease or
disorder based on the three dimensional structure of the crystallized
polypeptide or fragment; (c) contacting a dengue virus E protein or other
class II E protein with the potential compound; and (d) assaying the
activity of a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein, wherein a
change in the activity of the polypeptide indicates that the compound may be
useful for prevention or treatment of a flavivirus related disease or
disorder.
In another aspect, the present invention contemplates a method for designing
a potential compound for the prevention or treatment of flavivirus related
disease or disorder, the method comprising: (a) providing structural
information of a druggable region derived from NMR spectroscopy of a dengue
virus E protein or other class II E protein, or a fragment thereof; (b)
synthesizing a potential compound for the prevention or treatment of
flavivirus related disease or disorder based on the structural information;
(c) contacting a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein or a
flavivirus with the potential compound; and (d) assaying the activity of a
dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein, wherein a change in the
activity of the polypeptide indicates that the compound may be useful for
prevention or treatment of a flavivirus related disease or disorder. (b)
Modulator Libraries
The synthesis and screening of combinatorial libraries is a validated
strategy for the identification and study of organic molecules of interest.
According to the present invention, the synthesis of libraries containing
molecules bind, interact with, or modulate the activity/function of a
subject druggable region may be performed using established combinatorial
methods for solution phase, solid phase, or a combination of solution phase
and solid phase synthesis techniques. The synthesis of combinatorial
libraries is well known in the art and has been reviewed (see, e.g.,
"Combinatorial Chemistry", Chemical and Engineering News, Feb. 24, 1997, p.
43; Thompson et al., Chem. Rev. (1996) 96:555). Many libraries are
commercially available. One of ordinary skill in the art will realize that
the choice of method for any particular embodiment will depend upon the
specific number of molecules to be synthesized, the specific reaction
chemistry, and the availability of specific instrumentation, such as robotic
instrumentation for the preparation and analysis of the inventive libraries.
In certain embodiments, the reactions to be performed to generate the
libraries are selected for their ability to proceed in high yield, and in a
stereoselective and regioselective fashion, if applicable.
In one aspect of the present invention, the inventive libraries are
generated using a solution phase technique. Traditional advantages of
solution phase techniques for the synthesis of combinatorial libraries
include the availability of a much wider range of reactions, and the
relative ease with which products may be characterized, and ready
identification of library members, as discussed below. For example, in
certain embodiments, for the generation of a solution phase combinatorial
library, a parallel synthesis technique is utilized, in which all of the
products are assembled separately in their own reaction vessels. In a
particular parallel synthesis procedure, a microtitre plate containing n
rows and m columns of tiny wells which are capable of holding a few
milliliters of the solvent in which the reaction will occur, is utilized. It
is possible to then use n variants of reactant A, such as a ligand, and m
variants of reactant B, such as a second ligand, to obtain n.times.m
variants, in n.times.m wells. One of ordinary skill in the art will realize
that this particular procedure is most useful when smaller libraries are
desired, and the specific wells may provide a ready means to identify the
library members in a particular well.
In other embodiments of the present invention, a solid phase synthesis
technique is utilized. Solid phase techniques allow reactions to be driven
to completion because excess reagents may be utilized and the unreacted
reagent washed away. Solid phase synthesis also allows the use a technique
called "split and pool", in addition to the parallel synthesis technique,
developed by Furka. See, e.g., Furka et al., Abstr. 14th Int. Congr. Biochem.,
(Prague, Czechoslovakia) (1988) 5:47; Furka et al., Int. J. Pept. Protein
Res. (1991) 37:487; Sebestyen et al., Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. (1993) 3:413.
In this technique, a mixture of related molecules may be made in the same
reaction vessel, thus substantially reducing the number of containers
required for the synthesis of very large libraries, such as those containing
as many as or more than one million library members. As an example, the
solid support with the starting material attached may be divided into n
vessels, where n represents the number species of reagent A to be reacted
with the such starting material. After reaction, the contents from n vessels
are combined and then split into m vessels, where m represents the number of
species of reagent B to be reacted with the now modified starting materials.
This procedure is repeated until the desired number of reagents is reacted
with the starting materials to yield the inventive library.
The use of solid phase techniques in the present invention may also include
the use of a specific encoding technique. Specific encoding techniques have
been reviewed by Czarnik in Current Opinion in Chemical Biology (1997) 1:60.
One of ordinary skill in the art will also realize that if smaller solid
phase libraries are generated in specific reaction wells, such as 96 well
plates, or on plastic pins, the reaction history of these library members
may also be identified by their spatial coordinates in the particular plate,
and thus are spatially encoded. In other embodiments, an encoding technique
involves the use of a particular "identifying agent" attached to the solid
support, which enables the determination of the structure of a specific
library member without reference to its spatial coordinates. Examples of
such encoding techniques include, but are not limited to, spatial encoding
techniques, graphical encoding techniques, including the "tea bag" method,
chemical encoding methods, and spectrophotometric encoding methods. One of
ordinary skill in the art will realize that the particular encoding method
to be used in the present invention must be selected based upon the number
of library members desired, and the reaction chemistry employed.
In certain embodiments, molecules of the present invention may be prepared
using solid support chemistry known in the art. For example, polypeptides
having up to twenty amino acids or more may be generated using standard
solid phase technology on commercially available equipment (such as Advanced
Chemtech multiple organic synthesizers). In certain embodiments, a starting
material or later reactant may be attached to the solid phase, through a
linking unit, or directly, and subsequently used in the synthesis of desired
molecules. The choice of linkage will depend upon the reactivity of the
molecules and the solid support units and the stability of these linkages.
Direct attachment to the solid support via a linker molecule may be useful
if it is desired not to detach the library member from the solid support.
For example, for direct on-bead analysis of biological activity, a stronger
interaction between the library member and the solid support may be
desirable. Alternatively, the use of a linking reagent may be useful if more
facile cleavage of the inventive library members from the solid support is
desired.
In regard to automation of the present subject methods, a variety of
instrumentation may be used to allow for the facile and efficient
preparation of chemical libraries of the present invention, and methods of
assaying members of such libraries. In general, automation, as used in
reference to the synthesis and preparation of the subject chemical
libraries, involves having instrumentation complete one or more of the
operative steps that must be repeated a multitude of times because a library
instead of a single molecule is being prepared. Examples of automation
include, without limitation, having instrumentation complete the addition of
reagents, the mixing and reaction of them, filtering of reaction mixtures,
washing of solids with solvents, removal and addition of solvents, and the
like. Automation may be applied to any steps in a reaction scheme, including
those to prepare, purify and assay molecules for use in the compositions of
the present invention.
There is a range of automation possible. For example, the synthesis of the
subject libraries may be wholly automated or only partially automated. If
wholly automated, the subject library may be prepared by the instrumentation
without any human intervention after initiating the synthetic process, other
than refilling reagent bottles or monitoring or programming the
instrumentation as necessary. Although synthesis of a subject library may be
wholly automated, it may be necessary for there to be human intervention for
purification, identification, or the like of the library members.
In contrast, partial automation of the synthesis of a subject library
involves some robotic assistance with the physical steps of the reaction
schema that gives rise to the library, such as mixing, stirring, filtering
and the like, but still requires some human intervention other than just
refilling reagent bottles or monitoring or programming the instrumentation.
This type of robotic automation is distinguished from assistance provided by
convention organic synthetic and biological techniques because in partial
automation, instrumentation still completes one or more of the steps of any
schema that is required to be completed a multitude of times because a
library of molecules is being prepared.
In certain embodiments, the subject library may be prepared in multiple
reaction vessels (e.g., microtitre plates and the like), and the identity of
particular members of the library may be determined by the location of each
vessel. In other embodiments, the subject library may be synthesized in
solution, and by the use of deconvolution techniques, the identity of
particular members may be determined.
In one aspect of the invention, the subject screening method may be carried
out utilizing immobilized libraries. In certain embodiments, the immobilized
library will have the ability to bind to a microorganism as described above.
The choice of a suitable support will be routine to the skilled artisan.
Important criteria may include that the reactivity of the support not
interfere with the reactions required to prepare the library. Insoluble
polymeric supports include functionalized polymers based on polystyrene,
polystyrene/divinylbenzene copolymers, and the like, including any of the
particles described in section 4.3. It will be understood that the polymeric
support may be coated, grafted or otherwise bonded to other solid supports.
In another embodiment, the polymeric support may be provided by reversibly
soluble polymers. Such polymeric supports include functionalized polymers
based on polyvinyl alcohol or polyethylene glycol (PEG). A soluble support
may be made insoluble (e.g., may be made to precipitate) by addition of a
suitable inert nonsolvent. One advantage of reactions performed using
soluble polymeric supports is that reactions in solution may be more rapid,
higher yielding, and more complete than reactions that are performed on
insoluble polymeric supports.
Once the synthesis of either a desired solution phase or solid support bound
template has been completed, the template is then available for further
reaction to yield the desired solution phase or solid support bound
structure. The use of solid support bound templates enables the use of more
rapid split and pool techniques.
Characterization of the library members may be performed using standard
analytical techniques, such as mass spectrometry, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance
Spectroscopy, including 195Pt and 1H NMR, chromatography (e.g, liquid etc.)
and infra-red spectroscopy. One of ordinary skill in the art will realize
that the selection of a particular analytical technique will depend upon
whether the inventive library members are in the solution phase or on the
solid phase. In addition to such characterization, the library member may be
synthesized separately to allow for more ready identification. (c) In Vitro
Assays
Any form of dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein, e.g. a
full-length polypeptide or a fragment comprising the target druggable
region, may be used to assess the activity of candidate small molecules and
other modulators in in vitro assays. In one embodiment of such an assay,
agents are identified which modulate the biological activity of a druggable
region, the protein-protein interaction of interest or formation of a
protein complex involving a subject druggable region. In another embodiment
of such an assay, agents are identified which bind or interact with subject
druggable region. In certain embodiments, the test agent is a small organic
molecule. The candidate agents may be selected, for example, from the
following classes of compounds: detergents, proteins, peptides,
peptidomimetics, small molecules, cytokines, or hormones. In some
embodiments, the candidate therapeutics may be in a library of compounds.
These libraries may be generated using combinatorial synthetic methods as
described above. In certain embodiments of the present invention, the
ability of said candidate therapeutics to bind a target gene or gene product
may be evaluated by an in vitro assay. In either embodiments, discussed in
the next section, the binding assay may also be in vivo.
The invention also provides a method of screening multiple compounds to
identify those which modulate the action of polypeptides of the invention,
or polynucleotides encoding the same. The method of screening may involve
high-throughput techniques. For example, to screen for modulators, a
synthetic reaction mix, a cellular compartment, such as a membrane, cell
envelope or cell wall, or a preparation of any thereof, a whole cell or
tissue, or even a whole organism comprising a dengue virus E protein or
other class II E protein and a labeled substrate or ligand of such
polypeptide is incubated in the absence or the presence of a candidate
molecule that may be a modulator of a dengue virus E protein or other class
II E protein. The ability of the candidate molecule to modulate a dengue
virus E protein or other class II E protein is reflected in decreased
binding of the labeled ligand or decreased production of product from such
substrate. Detection of the rate or level of production of product from
substrate may be enhanced by using a reporter system. Reporter systems that
may be useful in this regard include but are not limited to calorimetric
labeled substrate converted into product, a reporter gene that is responsive
to changes in a nucleic acid of the invention or polypeptide activity, and
binding assays known in the art.
Another example of an assay for a modulator of a dengue virus E protein or
other class II E protein is a competitive assay that combines a dengue virus
E protein or other class II E protein and a potential modulator with
molecules that bind to a dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein,
recombinant molecules that bind to a dengue virus E protein or other class
II E protein, natural substrates or ligands, or substrate or ligand mimetics,
under appropriate conditions for a competitive inhibition assay.
Polypeptides of the invention can be labeled, such as by radioactivity or a
colorimetric compound, such that the number of molecules of a dengue virus E
protein or other class II E protein bound to a binding molecule or converted
to product can be determined accurately to assess the effectiveness of the
potential modulator.
A number of methods for identifying a molecule which modulates the activity
of a polypeptide are known in the art. For example, in one such method, a
dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein is contacted with a test
compound, and the activity of the dengue virus E protein or other class II E
protein in the presence of the test compound is determined, wherein a change
in the activity of the dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein is
indicative that the test compound modulates the activity of the dengue virus
E protein or other class II E protein. In certain instances, the test
compound agonizes the activity of the dengue virus E protein or other class
II E protein, and in other instances, the test compound antagonizes the
activity of the dengue virus E protein or other class II E protein.
In another example, a compound which modulates dengue virus E protein or
other class II E protein dependent growth or infectivity of flavivirus may
be identified by (a) contacting a dengue virus E protein or other class II E
protein with a test compound; and (b) determining the activity of the
polypeptide in the presence of the test compound, wherein a change in the
activity of the polypeptide is indicative that the test compound may
modulate the growth or infectivity of flavivirus.
In certain of the subject assays, to evaluate the results using the subject
compositions, comparisons may be made to known molecules, such as one with a
known binding affinity for the target. For example, a known molecule and a
new molecule of interest may be assayed. The result of the assay for the
subject complex will be of a type and of a magnitude that may be compared to
result for the known molecule. To the extent that the subject complex
exhibits a type of response in the assay that is quantifiably different from
that of the known molecule then the result for such complex in the assay
would be deemed a positive or negative result. In certain assays, the
magnitude of the response may be expressed as a percentage response with the
known molecule result, e.g. 100% of the known result if they are the same.
As those skilled in the art will understand, based on the present
description, binding assays may be used to detect agents that bind a
polypeptide. Cell-free assays may be used to identify molecules that are
capable of interacting with a polypeptide. In a preferred embodiment,
cell-free assays for identifying such molecules are comprised essentially of
a reaction mixture containing a target and a test molecule or a library of
test molecules. A test molecule may be, e.g., a derivative of a known
binding partner of the target, e.g., a biologically inactive peptide, or a
small molecule. Agents to be tested for their ability to bind may be
produced, for example, by bacteria, yeast or other organisms (e.g. natural
products), produced chemically (e.g. small molecules, including
peptidomimetics), or produced recombinantly. In certain embodiments, the
test molecule is selected from the group consisting of lipids,
carbohydrates, peptides, peptidomimetics, peptide-nucleic acids (PNAs),
proteins, small molecules, natural products, aptamers and oligonucleotides.
In other embodiments of the invention, the binding assays are not cell-free.
In a preferred embodiment, such assays for identifying molecules that bind a
target comprise a reaction mixture containing a target microorganism and a
test molecule or a library of test molecules.
In many candidate screening programs which test libraries of molecules and
natural extracts, high throughput assays are desirable in order to maximize
the number of molecules surveyed in a given period of time. Assays of the
present invention which are performed in cell-free systems, such as may be
derived with purified or semi-purified proteins or with lysates, are often
preferred as "primary" screens in that they may be generated to permit rapid
development and relatively easy detection of binding between a target and a
test molecule. Moreover, the effects of cellular toxicity and/or
bioavailability of the test molecule may be generally ignored in the in
vitro system, the assay instead being focused primarily on the ability of
the molecule to bind the target. Accordingly, potential binding molecules
may be detected in a cell-free assay generated by constitution of functional
interactions of interest in a cell lysate. In an alternate format, the assay
may be derived as a reconstituted protein mixture which, as described below,
offers a number of benefits over lysate-based assays.
In one aspect, the present invention provides assays that may be used to
screen for molecules that bind E protein druggable regions. In an exemplary
binding assay, the molecule of interest is contacted with a mixture
generated from target cell surface polypeptides. Detection and
quantification of expected binding from to a target polypeptide provides a
means for determining the molecule's efficacy at binding the target. The
efficacy of the molecule may be assessed by generating dose response curves
from data obtained using various concentrations of the test molecule.
Moreover, a control assay may also be performed to provide a baseline for
comparison. In the control assay, the formation of complexes is quantitated
in the absence of the test molecule.
Complex formation between a molecule and a target E protein or microorganism
containing a class II E protein may be detected by a variety of techniques,
many of which are effectively described above. For instance, modulation in
the formation of complexes may be quantitated using, for example, detectably
labeled proteins (e.g. radiolabeled, fluorescently labeled, or enzymatically
labeled), by immunoassay, or by chromatographic detection.
Accordingly, one exemplary screening assay of the present invention includes
the steps of contacting a class II E protein or functional fragment thereof
with a test molecule or library of test molecules and detecting the
formation of complexes. For detection purposes, for example, the molecule
may be labeled with a specific marker and the test molecule or library of
test molecules labeled with a different marker. Interaction of a test
molecule with a polypeptide or fragment thereof may then be detected by
determining the level of the two labels after an incubation step and a
washing step. The presence of two labels after the washing step is
indicative of an interaction. Such an assay may also be modified to work
with a whole target cell.
An interaction between a class II E protein target and a molecule may also
be identified by using real-time BIA (Biomolecular Interaction Analysis,
Pharmacia Biosensor AB) which detects surface plasmon resonance (SPR), an
optical phenomenon. Detection depends on changes in the mass concentration
of macromolecules at the biospecific interface, and does not require any
labeling of interactants. In one embodiment, a library of test molecules may
be immobilized on a sensor surface, e.g., which forms one wall of a
micro-flow cell. A solution containing the target is then flowed
continuously over the sensor surface. A change in the resonance angle as
shown on a signal recording, indicates that an interaction has occurred.
This technique is further described, e.g., in BIAtechnology Handbook by
Pharmacia.
In a preferred embodiment, it will be desirable to immobilize the target to
facilitate separation of complexes from uncomplexed forms, as well as to
accommodate automation of the assay. Binding of polypeptide to a test
molecule may be accomplished in any vessel suitable for containing the
reactants. Examples include microtitre plates, test tubes, and
micro-centrifuge tubes. In one embodiment, a fusion protein may be provided
which adds a domain that allows the target to be bound to a matrix. For
example, glutathione-S-transferase/polypeptide (GST/polypeptide) fusion
proteins may be adsorbed onto glutathione sepharose beads (Sigma Chemical,
St. Louis, Mo.) or glutathione derivatized microtitre plates, which are then
combined with a labeled test molecule (e.g., S.sup.35 labeled, P.sup.33
labeled, and the like, and the mixture incubated under conditions conducive
to complex formation, e.g. at physiological conditions for salt and pH,
though slightly more stringent conditions may be desired. Following
incubation, the beads are washed to remove any unbound label, and the matrix
immobilized and radiolabel determined directly (e.g. beads placed in
scintillant), or in the supernatant after the complexes are subsequently
dissociated. Alternatively, the complexes may be dissociated from the
matrix, separated by SDS-PAGE, and the level of polypeptide or binding
partner found in the bead fraction quantitated from the gel using standard
electrophoretic techniques such as described in the appended examples. The
above techniques could also be modified in which the test molecule is
immobilized, and the labeled target is incubated with the immobilized test
molecules. In one embodiment of the invention, the test molecules are
immobilized, optionally via a linker, to a particle of the invention, e.g.
to create the ultimate composition.
Other techniques for immobilizing targets or molecules on matrices may be
used in the subject assays. For instance, a target or molecule may be
immobilized utilizing conjugation of biotin and streptavidin. For instance,
biotinylated polypeptide molecules may be prepared from biotin-NHS(N-hydroxy-succinimide)
using techniques well known in the art (e.g., biotinylation kit, Pierce
Chemicals, Rockford, Ill.), and immobilized in the wells of streptavidin-coated
96 well plates (Pierce Chemical). Alternatively, antibodies reactive with a
target or molecule may be derivatized to the wells of the plate, and the
target or molecule trapped in the wells by antibody conjugation. As above,
preparations of test molecules are incubated in the polypeptide presenting
wells of the plate, and the amount of complex trapped in the well may be
quantitated. Exemplary methods for detecting such complexes, in addition to
those described above for the GST-immobilized complexes, include
immunodetection of complexes using antibodies reactive with the complex, or
which are reactive with one of the complex components; as well as
enzyme-linked assays which rely on detecting an enzymatic activity
associated with a target or molecule, either intrinsic or extrinsic
activity. In an instance of the latter, the enzyme may be chemically
conjugated or provided as a fusion protein with the target or molecule. To
illustrate, a target polypeptide may be chemically cross-linked or
genetically fused with horseradish peroxidase, and the amount of polypeptide
trapped in a complex with a molecule may be assessed with a chromogenic
substrate of the enzyme, e.g. 3,3'-diamino-benzadine terahydrochloride or
4-chloro-1-napthol. Likewise, a fusion protein comprising the polypeptide
and glutathione-S-transferase may be provided, and complex formation
quantitated by detecting the GST activity using 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene
(Habig et al (1974) J Biol Chem 249:7130).
For processes that rely on immunodetection for quantitating one of the
components trapped in a complex, antibodies against a component, such as
anti-polypeptide antibodies, may be used. Alternatively, the component to be
detected in the complex may be "epitope tagged" in the form of a fusion
protein which includes, in addition to the polypeptide sequence, a second
polypeptide for which antibodies are readily available (e.g. from commercial
sources). For instance, the GST fusion proteins described above may also be
used for quantification of binding using antibodies against the GST moiety.
Other useful epitope tags include myc-epitopes (e.g., see Ellison et al.
(1991) J Biol Chem 266:21150-21157) which includes a 10-residue sequence
from c-myc, as well as the pFLAG system (International Biotechnologies,
Inc.) or the pEZZ-protein A system (Pharmacia, N.J.).
In certain in vitro embodiments of the present assay, the solution
containing the target comprises a reconstituted protein mixture of at least
semi-purified proteins. By semi-purified, it is meant that the components
utilized in the reconstituted mixture have been previously separated from
other cellular or viral proteins. For instance, in contrast to cell lysates,
a target protein is present in the mixture to at least 50% purity relative
to all other proteins in the mixture, and more preferably are present at
90-95% purity. In certain embodiments of the subject method, the
reconstituted protein mixture is derived by mixing highly purified proteins
such that the reconstituted mixture substantially lacks other proteins (such
as of cellular or viral origin) which might interfere with or otherwise
alter the ability to measure binding activity. In one embodiment, the use of
reconstituted protein mixtures allows more careful control of the
target:molecule interaction conditions.
In still other embodiments of the present invention, variations of viral
fusion or viral infectivity assays may be utilized in order to determine the
ability of a test molecule to prevent a virus expressing type II E protein
from binding to, fusing with, or infecting cells. If fusion, binding, or
infecting is prevented, then the molecule or composition may be useful as a
therapeutic agent.
All of the screening methods may be accomplished by using a variety of assay
formats. In light of the present disclosure, those not expressly described
herein will nevertheless be known and comprehended by one of ordinary skill
in the art. Assay formats which approximate such conditions as formation of
protein complexes or protein-nucleic acid complexes, and enzymatic activity
may be generated in many different forms, as those skilled in the art will
appreciate based on the present description and include but are not limited
to assays based on cell-free systems, e.g. purified proteins or cell lysates,
as well as cell-based assays which utilize intact cells. Assaying binding
resulting from a given target:molecule interaction may be accomplished in
any vessel suitable for containing the reactants. Examples include
microtitre plates, test tubes, and micro-centrifuge tubes. Any of the assays
may be provided in kit format and may be automated. Many of the following
particularized assays rely on general principles, such as blockage or
prevention of fusion, that may apply to other particular assays. (d) In Vivo
Assays
Animal models of viral infection and/or disease may be used as an in vivo
assay for evaluating the effectiveness of a potential drug target in
treating or preventing flavivirus related diseases or disorders. A number of
suitable animal models are described briefly below, however, these models
are only examples and modifications, or completely different animal models,
may be used in accord with the methods of the invention. Animal models may
be developed by methods known in the art, for example, by infecting an
animal with dengue fever or another flavivirus, or by genetically
engineering an animal to be predisposed to such infection (see, e.g., Wu,
S.-J. L. et al. Evaluation of the severe combined immunodeficient (SCID)
mouse as an animal model for dengue viral infection. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg.
52, 468-476 (1995)).
Further, viral infectivity assays may be used as in vivo assays to assess
the effectiveness of a potential drug target in treating or preventing
flavivirus related diseases or disorders. For example, the plaque assays
described in Diamond et al (2000) J Virol 74:4957-4966 may be used to assess
by analyzing virion production whether an agent may modulate infectivity of
Dengue virus. Other assays, such as competitive, asymmetric reverse
transcriptase-mediated PCR (RT-PCR) assays and flow cytometric assays that
measure viral antigen, also described in Diamond, et al, may be used to
assess the effectiveness of a potential drug target.
Still further, further, cell-cell fusion assays may be used as in vivo
assays to assess the effectiveness of a potential drug target in treating or
preventing flavivirus related diseases or disorders. For example, a
cell-cell fusion assay in which the cell membrane fusion activity of dengue
virus may be analyzed is described in Despres et al (1993) Virology
196:209-219.
A variety of other in vivo models are available and may be used when
appropriate for specific pathogens or specific test agents.
It is also relevant to note that the species of animal used for an infection
model, and the specific genetic make-up of that animal, may contribute to
the effective evaluation of the effects of a particular test agent. For
example, immuno-incompetent animals may, in some instances, be preferable to
immuno-competent animals. For example, the action of a competent immune
system may, to some degree, mask the effects of the test agent as compared
to a similar infection in an immuno-incompetent animal. In addition, many
opportunistic infections, in fact, occur in immuno-compromised patients, so
modeling an infection in a similar immunological environment is appropriate.
E. Pharmaceutical Compositions
Pharmaceutical compositions of this invention include any modulator
identified according to the present invention, or a pharmaceutically
acceptable salt thereof, and a pharmaceutically acceptable carrier,
adjuvant, or vehicle. The term "pharmaceutically acceptable carrier" refers
to a carrier(s) that is "acceptable" in the sense of being compatible with
the other ingredients of a composition and not deleterious to the recipient
thereof.
Methods of making and using such pharmaceutical compositions are also
included in the invention. The pharmaceutical compositions of the invention
can be administered orally, parenterally, by inhalation spray, topically,
rectally, nasally, buccally, vaginally, or via an implanted reservoir. The
term parenteral as used herein includes subcutaneous, intracutaneous,
intravenous, intramuscular, intra articular, intrasynovial, intrasternal,
intrathecal, intralesional, and intracranial injection or infusion
techniques.
Dosage levels of between about 0.01 and about 100 mg/kg body weight per day,
preferably between about 0.5 and about 75 mg/kg body weight per day of the
modulators described herein are useful for the prevention and treatment of
disease and conditions, including diseases and conditions mediated by
pathogenic species of origin for the polypeptides of the invention. The
amount of active ingredient that may be combined with the carrier materials
to produce a single dosage form will vary depending upon the host treated
and the particular mode of administration. A typical preparation will
contain from about 5% to about 95% active compound (w/w). Alternatively,
such preparations contain from about 20% to about 80% active compound.
G. Kits
The present invention provides kits for treating dengue fever and other
flaviviral infections. For example, a kit may comprise compositions
comprising compounds identified herein as modulators of dengue virus E
protein or other class II E protein. The compositions may be pharmaceutical
compositions comprising a pharmaceutically acceptable excipient. In other
embodiments involving kits, this invention contemplates a kit including
compositions of the present invention, and optionally instructions for their
use. Kit components may be packaged for either manual or partially or wholly
automated practice of the foregoing methods. Such kits may have a variety of
uses, including, for example, imaging, diagnosis, therapy, and other
applications.
H. Further Characterization of Dengue Virus E Protein or Other Flavivirus E
Protein Druggable Regions and Complexes of the Same
Claim 1 of 18 Claims
1. A method for identifying a candidate
therapeutic for a disease caused by a virus having class II E protein,
comprising contacting a dengue virus class II E protein with a compound,
wherein binding of said compound indicates a candidate therapeutic,
wherein the dengue virus class II E protein consists of an amino acid
sequence at least 20 amino acids but not greater than 394 amino acids in
length having at least 85% identity along the length to the amino acid
sequence of SEQ ID NO: 1 or 2, wherein amino acid residue 101 is Trp,
amino acid residue 107 is Leu and amino acid residue 108 is Phe when
numbered in accordance with SEQ ID NO: 1 or 2. ____________________________________________
If you want to learn more
about this patent, please go directly to the U.S.
Patent and Trademark Office Web site to access the full
patent.
|